Las Vegas Sun

January 27, 2015

Currently: 55° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account


Again, legislators fail to stand up for Southern Nevada

Another view?

View more of the Las Vegas Sun's opinion section:

Editorials - the Sun's viewpoint.

Columnists - local and syndicated writers.

Letters to the editor - readers' views.

Have your own opinion? Write a letter to the editor.

Show us the money, Governor.

With the end of the 2013 Legislature in sight, the kudos going around the Legislative Building are enough to make one think that something good happened these past few months.

If you were one or two of the state’s major industries, then something good did happen, as it probably should. But if you were one of the 2 million people who live in Southern Nevada, where more than 70 percent of the state’s population lives, then there is not much good to report.

When the Legislature meets, the rhetoric of the political campaigns almost always turns into just so many words hollowed out by the political reality that, whether people like to admit it, turns on a north-vs.-south competition that the south is determined to lose. Every time.

Don’t get me wrong; I am not just squeezing some sour grapes. Having lived in this state and having been an observer of all things legislative, I can say with confidence that the millions of people who live in Clark County have, once again, done the bidding of the hundreds of thousands of people who live in the north and who have come to expect that for the past century.

And we make it so.

There will be hand-shaking, high-fiving and some glowing reports about how what the governor accomplished — without raising taxes — was miraculous. And the southern-based senators and assembly members will come back home either lamenting or secretly extolling the virtues of the two-thirds vote needed to raise new revenues in this state.

The northern politicos will rightly go back to their fiefdoms as victors, having vanquished, once again, all real efforts for some fairness in a system that has been rigged against Las Vegas since the 1950s.

And Gov. Brian Sandoval will characteristically crow about how he saved the state from taxing itself to death while repairing some of the damage inflicted on our public education system and the tens of thousands of school-aged children who will forever suffer from this madness.

And all will be well in the kingdom.

Except that there has to come a time when the people who have the ability to decide a political race in this state actually get off their butts and vote in their own interests. And when that happens, look out.

I wrote a couple of weeks ago about a very simple fix to what ails us in Southern Nevada and what it would take to start getting a few hundred million dollars headed our way.

While it wouldn’t solve the school problems directly, it would have the benefit of making sure that Southern Nevada, as the economic engine for the entire state, got the kind of roads and transportation systems it needs in order to create jobs and advance the cause of commerce. That, in turn, would create the impetus for fixing our schools and create the ability and tax revenues to pay for it.

The fix is simple. Since much of the federal money returned to the states is based on population, the Legislature should have mandated that it be distributed the same way once it gets here. And, further, the representation of Southern Nevada on the state Transportation Board — the group that determines when and how to spend the money on transportation needs — would be based on the same thing: population.

Over 200 years ago there was a catchphrase: “No taxation without representation.” It was strong enough in its appeal to capture the imagination of a bunch of colonists who decided to have a tea party (a real, patriotic tea party) in Boston Harbor. The rest is a brilliant history about democracy, majority rule and, yes, no taxation without representation.

What the 2013 Legislature and our good governor have managed to do — albeit there is a little time left in this session — is absolutely nothing toward providing the people in Southern Nevada with anything close to adequate representation when it comes to how our tax dollars are raised and how they are spent.

The governor has been aided and abetted by Southern Nevada’s legislators of both parties who have caved in at every turn to the demands of their northern brethren.

I had high hopes for Senate Minority Leader Michael Roberson, who came across as a moderate Republican leader from the South. The first chance he got, he embraced Sandoval’s stiff-arming of Clark County. In millions of different ways.

Senate Majority Leader Mo Denis and Speaker Marilyn Kirkpatrick, the two Democratic leaders from the south, sounded like they had the right stuff, but when push came to shove, they allowed themselves to get shoved around by other Democrats. Even though the south had all the numbers in our favor, they capitulated for fear of, what, upsetting the governor? How about upsetting the lives and dreams of tens of thousands of schoolchildren and the hopes and aspirations of hundreds of thousands of Nevadans who expect words like “fair share” and “one for all” to actually mean something?

No, this is not griping just for the frustrating sake of griping. I write this for two reasons.

First: I don’t want our governor and our “legislative leaders” to think they got away with anything by pulling the wool over the eyes of Southern Nevadans. What they got away with is just another big stall tactic designed to short-change the people of Clark County in favor of Reno and the cow counties. Yes, we are suckers yet again, but we know it and we know what you have done.

Second: to sound a warning of what is bad for the entire state. Frustrate us too much and the people will go to the ballot box with so many initiatives we will make Californians jealous. Government by initiative is a proven to way to break a state, but if the Legislature and governor won’t do what is right then the time will come when the people will do what is necessary, no matter how wrong it may be.

But it doesn’t have to be this way. Does it, Governor?

Brian Greenspun is publisher and editor of the Las Vegas Sun.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 8 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. I have to think that if Warren Buffet is willing to invest $10 Billion in Nevada Power, he must see some positive economic signs for the state and its people. If Buffet does, and obviously he must, that has to be in some large part to Governor Sandoval and his accomplishments.

    Carmine D

  2. PS:

    Buffet is a democrat.

    Carmine D

  3. There never has been, nor will there ever be a Republican that looks out for the middle class. The sole purpose of republicans clinging to power is to disenfranchise the less fortunate, I got mine and yours will trickle down in a future that will never see the light of day.

    The problem is a lack of leadership for the Democrats and their inclinations to fall prey to any con the republicans can dream up.
    Apparently there are no Democrats that have any money and the GOP wants to keep it that way. Which is why the status quo will continue unabated for ever.

  4. Warren Buffet sees an investment that makes a consistent profit margin of 10%+ and as a business man he's knows that is an above average profit. Buffet's party affiliation or sentiment about Nevada play no part in his investment.

    As usual, Carmine DiFazio has made a false assumption.

  5. "As usual, Carmine DiFazio has made a false assumption."

    Only in your mind.

    Warren Buffett once said owning a utility was a way to stay rich rather than get rich. He was being coy. Las Vegas is a safe bet.

    Nevada's population growth is projected to be about 50 percent faster than the U.S. average over this decade.

    NV Energy will likely overhaul its power generation production to cut reliance on coal.

    Both underpin profit growth which means getting rich.

    Carmine D

  6. Beyond disappointment with Southern Nevada Lawmakers. As the People of Southern Nevada continue to suffer in the quality of living, these Lawmakers shy away from crossing the Governor at every turn. The 2 party system of governance is not working. This is proof.

    I echo Brian Greenspun's sentiments. The voters of Southern Nevada are truly apathic. Just go to any home or ranch in Northern Nevada, and they are 7/24 on politics in nearly every conversation, including church! Here in Southern Nevada, people only pay attention when maybe they vote. Geez

    It is a shame that Nevadans will begin to see initiatives surface, to meet the needs of the People, and Greenspun suggests, "Frustrate us too much and the people will go to the ballot box with so many initiatives we will make Californians jealous."

    I know that there are plenty of folks ready to go that route because of the continual frustration with each and every passing Nevada Legislative Session that goes by without tending to the needs of the People here in Southern Nevada. Shame on Lawmakers.

    At the bottom of the world OECD nations ratings for math and science is Mexico, the main feeder nation to the United States of America, which adversely impacts education here in our country. This has dragged down our educational system's achievement results and quality of education for STEM. Our Lawmakers need to address such disparities with increased funding to educational programs that will get these ELL students AND their parents up to speed with our educational standards.

    Blessings and Peace,

  7. Totally agree with you, Mr. Greenspun, about the ballot box being used more.

    Our State Government is completely fractured. Even when something needs to get doesn't. Why? Because of nothing but stupid party politics.

    The politicians can't do their job.


    WE, the good people of Nevada, put this stuff out as initiatives and vote for it. Let the politicians fight us on this all they want to represent their special interests, but WE will not be denied.

    They can't do their jobs? Fine. WE do it.

    They are supposed to serve us. Not the other way around.

    We take this stuff directly to the people. Do an end around the politicians in power. Maybe that will wake them up and make them smell the coffee.

  8. I think the article would be Much more useful by naming specific bills, their mission and the Clark County Politician that voted against it. Without having to read a novel please.