Las Vegas Sun

January 30, 2015

Currently: 57° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Jon Ralston:

Much at stake economically, politically in Station, Culinary fight

An escalating conflict between the city’s dominant, homegrown casino company and the state’s most aggressive, successful labor organization has emerged from the shadows of resorts to the brightness of the public square, threatening to force politicians to take sides and to inflict collateral damage on others inside and outside Nevada.

The Culinary Union’s cutthroat, guerilla tactics, used for years against casinos with Strip ZIP codes, have been deployed for months now against locals goliath Station. But the previously sub rosa effort, which has included complaints with federal authorities and letters to potential Station customers, now has sparked a multimedia counterattack unlike any the union — or Las Vegas — has ever seen.

(Go to my blog at to see samples of the Station and Culinary campaigns. You can also see Thursday’s Station vs. Culinary on “Face to Face With Jon Ralston.”)

The stakes here are enormous, especially for the union, and are much broader than whether this conflagration allows the Culinary in the door at Station properties after decades of trying. After a year in which other vaunted unions — especially the firefighters — saw a public backlash as the economy worsened and government tanked, the Culinary is vulnerable during a time in which other working folks are thankful just to have a job or angry about not having one.

For years, Local 226 has been seen as perhaps the most potent grassroots political force in Nevada, able to singlehandedly sway elections, mostly in local and legislative contests. But the union suffered a blow in 2008 when it went out on a limb for Barack Obama only to see Hillary Clinton, aided by her husband and others, win the state by 5 percentage points.

Now, on the cusp of another presidential year, and with critical races for the U.S. Senate, the Legislature and Clark County Commission, the Culinary is taking on a political player that has only become more influential, pouring money into elected official coffers from Carson City to Grand Central Parkway.

The Station ad campaign is motivated both by frustration and anger at the Culinary tactics, which have included websites to pillory board members and companies deemed too friendly to Station (Zappos) as well as those letters to potential guests and performers. The union has been relentless, as it always is, writing to entertainers and convention organizers, outlining the National Labor Relations Board complaint that has yielded a preliminary victory on 87 counts — that is, they were not dismissed. In one missive to an agent of a performer at Red Rock Resort, the union wrote, “Station Casinos is mired in an ugly, contentious labor dispute that is creating growing ill will in the Las Vegas community.”

The Station response has been to try to create some ill will of its own in the community toward the Culinary, with a series of ads portraying the union as a job-killer, not job-creator. And the Fertittas are a different strain from others the Culinary has run its marathon campaigns against, integrated into the community and power structure in a way few Culinary foes ever have been. They may engender sympathy that the union does not anticipate.

Some who have been here awhile will feel a sense of déjà vu, with the argument of the union insisting on employees simply signing a card to embrace the union vs. Station saying a secret-ballot election is allowed and welcomed. Both sides are disingenuous on this, with the union knowing how much easier a card check process is — and casinos have submitted in the past — and the employer having many advantages to dissuade, even intimidate, if a secret ballot were to occur.

Station, ironically, seems to have Culinary-like resolve, buttressed by the Ferttitas’ pride and deep pockets as well as the reality that no other locals company has been unionized, so it’s a competitive imperative, too. This is an endurance test the company seems prepared to win, going so far as to hire former union ally Mike Sloan to help plot strategy.

The Culinary, too, shows no signs of relenting and last year expanded its assault to the jewel in the Fertitta crown, the Ultimate Fighting Championship, sending boss Dana White into rhetorical paroxysms of fury caught on camera. Maybe White will be featured in the next round of anti-Culinary ads?

I also wonder if the Culinary can count on the support it has enjoyed in the past from the Democratic political elite. Many Democrats, warned by the union about having events on Station properties, are raking in the company’s cash as the year begins.

And therein lies the real collateral damage that may occur as, sooner or later, folks in the political and business worlds are going to be asked to take sides in a labor-management war that could make the ones since the 1984 Strip strike look tame.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 7 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Now how does this compare to the continuous comments about Wall Street power and greed? Same thing, different people. Neither should be allowed to have so much influence.

  2. If the union was really out for the good of the employees they would just let them hold a secret ballot vote, up or down.

    The Union does not want that because they know that most of the 13,000+ employees do not have any interest in their union.

    The union is acting like the old mob days, do it our way or we will hurt your company. They have failed for more then 20 years of chasing Stations and they are making it personal. They want the dues from 13,000 people that don't want them.

    When the union started contacting clients of the conventions coming to town they stepped way over the line. Contacting the promoters is one thing, contacting their clients is taking it to far.

    When does the law finally step up and put a stop to the harassment? Is there no bounds this union won't go to get their way?

    They are right, it is making many in the community feel bad, bad towards the union! If they keep this up maybe it is time to start a drive to not support any of the union businesses, then the big union houses will get the union back in line.

  3. The rules of the National Labor Relations Board require a Petition for an election supported by 30% of the employees of the proposed bargaining unit -- BUT no election can be held while claims of unfair labor practices are pending and unresolved.

  4. Culinary - If you didn't know the players and were told this story with different names, as in decades ago in a different country you would recognize them for the commie thugs they are.

  5. I happen to like the various promotions in the Stations' poker rooms, even though they have been scaled back quite a bit over the last year or so.

    I have little doubt that were Culinary to gain a foothold there the promotions would be scaled back much further still, right when it looks like business might be getting a little better thanks to the changes Stations has made over the last 6 months to the Boarding Pass system.

  6. RE Bob Realist. GM now the largest auto maker in the world.

    RE boftx. What does the culinary union have to do with poker room promotions?

  7. I love their commercials where they stick a camera in an employees face and have them record how great their boss is. No intimidation there now.