NIAA’s realignment debate continues

Wednesday, Sept. 16, 2009 | 5 p.m.

Jeff Newton (Lake Mead Christian Academy, 1A Liaison)
Bill Darrow (Needles High School, 2A Liaison)
David Wilson (Virgin Valley High School Principal)
Pam Sloan (CCSD Coordinator of Activities)
Betsy Angelcor (Del Sol High School Principal)
Kevin McPartlin (Chaparral High School Principal)
Neddy Alvarez (Western High School Principal)
Tammy Malich (Legacy High School Principal)
Greg Wolfram (Arbor View High School Athletic Administrator)
Brian McAllister (Cimarron-Memorial High School Athletic Administrator)
Larry Goins (Desert Oasis High School Athletic Director)
Xavier Antheaume (Liberty High School Athletic Director)

Realignment proposed for high school sports (5/11/09)

High school sports section

Forget health care reform; try settling a high school sports realignment debate.

Nearly 100 parents, coaches and administrators packed the Del Sol High School library Wednesday morning to voice their opinions on the sensitive issue at the Nevada Interscholastic Athletics Association Board of Control meeting.

Since the NIAA floated a hypothetical three-division realignment in May, many parents and coaches have voiced outrage about an apparent drop from a 4A to 3A classification for schools such as Basic and Chaparral.

Some media outlets initially reported the proposal would include football, which only created further dissent.

"This plan never included football and it never will," said Eddie Bonine, the NIAA executive director. "I was asked by the state's 17 superintendents to explore options to reduce the financial strain caused by sports in an effort to avoid having to completely cut some athletics programs. A football realignment will be completed separate from the other sports."

The NIAA explained Wednesday that there is no tangible plan in place for realignment to support or oppose.

The organization will, however, create a realignment committee to explore options and create a proposal by March. Realignment would then go into effect for the 2010-2011 school year.

Southern Nevada's realignment committee, which is comprised of five principals, two athletic directors and various other school personnel, will hold its first meeting at 10 a.m. on Oct. 21 at Legacy High School.

Even that announcement met some criticism on Wednesday as many parents expressed their desire to maintain the status quo.

"Let's keep things the way they are," said Theresa Cooper of the Chaparral area. "Moving our school down is unfair and it would negatively impact our kids."

The notion of dropping down or moving up in classification struck some administrators as a jarring sentiment.

"If you are an athlete, it does not matter what level you are playing, colleges are going to come recruit you. Period," said Virgin Valley principal David Wilson. "It doesn't matter if you are 4A, 3A, 2A or 1A. If you are an athlete they will come after you."

But what troubled many was the lack of transparency in the realignment selection criteria with competitiveness, enrollment numbers and athletic participation all potential factors.

Travel costs and the number of games could also play a role in determining how city schools stack up to rural schools.

"Everyone wants to face the best competition," said Basic High principal David Bechtel said. "The bottom line is schools are different in the city. The problems we face are different in the city than the rural schools. You can't take a Laughlin model and use it in Clark County. Basic is different from other schools. We are a small, tight-knit community that does not want (a classification drop)."

While schools such as Basic, Chaparral and Del Sol are fighting to remain in the top division, perennial powers like Las Vegas High want steady competition rather than regular blowouts.

"We are fighting to get teams to throw their best pitcher to our players so we can compete," said Las Vegas High principal Debbie Brockett. "So I understand realignment might not work best if it is based on a competitive level… I think it is important to look at realignment for financial reasons. We do not want to have to make choices about cutting entire programs."

Realigning schools unilaterally is certainly not an easy task with certain schools dominating in baseball while others struggle to field a tennis team.

But the main point of contention is still about football.

Bonine proposed one idea that would create a separate all Southern Nevada football league that would not have to incur travel costs for state tournaments — a 5A classification with no real state championship, but a way to preserve traditional rivalries.

Ultimately, a concrete realignment plan to debate is still many months away.

In addition to the formation of realignment committees, the NIAA also decided to push an emergency agenda to revise its athletic physical forms and approve what type of medical personnel can conduct these physicals.

Several nurse practitioners and chiropractors lobbied to remain eligible to perform the mandatory physicals.

The NIAA will meet again at 9 a.m. Thursday at Del Sol High School to discuss other non-realignment issues.

Steve Silver can be reached at 948-7822 or steve.silver@lasvegassun.com.

Discussion: 7 comments so far…

By sunset

9/16/09 at 8:57 p.m.

Suggest removal

That's a tough one. I don't envy the committee members.
By dcvegas80

9/17/09 at 9:42 a.m.

Suggest removal

Forget this Division I, II and III proposal... I have created my own classification realignment that introduces Class 5A to Nevada, and makes things much more fair, clear and balanced. Plus, NO ONE DROPS CLASSIFICATION. You either stay put or move up. Unlike the short amount of time put into the "Fielder" realignment plan, I spent time getting honest feedback from members of the media in the state as to where they would place teams. If you would like to see what I have come up with, e-mail me at dan-dot-cabrera at csn-dot-edu. That's dan.cabrera@csn.edu and I will email you a copy.
By dcvegas80

9/17/09 at 9:51 a.m.

Suggest removal

I should also note that my realignment plan DOES include football.
By SteveSilver (Staff)

9/17/09 at 1:28 p.m.

Suggest removal

DCvegas, I'll take you over Fielder any day.
By dcvegas80

9/17/09 at 2:13 p.m.

Suggest removal

Yeah, Fielder's plan is just a carbon copy of what the NIAA wants to do. After all, Fielder's employer is one of the NIAA's title sponsors.
By SteveSilver (Staff)

9/17/09 at 2:32 p.m.

Suggest removal

What? Here I thought Fielder was actually a high school kid writing that all along?

The NIAA and the RJ are interchangeable. They pay for coverage. Yet somehow my boy Brewer and the rest of the Sun staff keeps pumping out the best prep football coverage in the city.

I'm fired up for tonight and I know you are DC.
By dcvegas80

9/17/09 at 2:54 p.m.

Suggest removal

Yes I am! Should be an exciting night of football!

And of course I agree the Sun staff kills the RJ at prep sports coverage.

« Previous Ten Next Ten »

Area Football Teams

See bigger map

Scoring Alerts

Sign up and we'll send you updates after each quarter for every game we cover each week. We also will soon provide an e-mail newsletter every Friday and Saturday with previews and recaps from around the Valley.

All alerts »

Latest Stories

prep football:

Gorman coach doesn't let disability slow him down

Limited to a wheelchair, Adam Hutchins has earned his stripes in Gaels' program

Adam Hutchins has always had to compensate for his disability. When the other football coaches at Bishop Gorman High instruct their players by showing them the proper technique or by giving an example of how a play should look, Hutchins, a paraplegic, isn’t able to ...