Las Vegas Sun

March 29, 2024

Where I Stand:

Scary message: Signs point to another intifada

Perception is reality.

It also can be very dangerous. My friend Uri Dromi has written a piece that should send both shivers down the spine and a message to the brains of those who seek a just, secure and lasting peace in the Middle East.

I’m reprinting it below.

The message I get from Uri is that now would be a very good time for someone to step back into the Middle East morass and let reality dictate our course before perception — wrong as it may be — leads us to a very dark place.

— Brian Greenspun

Earlier this month, Khalil Shikaki, director of the Ramallah-based Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research, addressed the Jerusalem Press Club.

Shikaki, who has been polling Palestinian public opinion since 1993, shared with the journalists the findings of three polls he had conducted since the end of the war in Gaza.

Shikaki spoke softly, but his message was scary. He found that for Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank, the last Gaza war ended with a victory for Hamas, and that, as a result, the terror movement and its approach of armed resistance had become much more popular.

Conditions like those that existed in 2000 are in place. According to his survey, for the first time since 2006, Hamas has enough support to win elections if they were to take place today. He also found that West Bank residents are increasingly backing Hamas’s approach. Among those surveyed, 86 percent supported the firing of rockets from Gaza if the siege and blockade are not lifted, and 53 percent believed that armed confrontation was the most effective means to establish a Palestinian state. Only 22 percent believed talks were the best path.

Does this mean we are facing another intifada? Shikaki, ever the cautious academic, refused to speculate.

However, he told us about a poll he had conducted in the summer of 2000. This was immediately after the failure of the talks in Camp David and the unilateral Israeli pullout from Lebanon. For the Palestinians, these events signified that the political-diplomatic avenue was leading nowhere: for them, it was Hezbollah’s armed struggle that had kicked Israel off Arab land. It took Ariel Sharon’s trip to Temple Mount to spark the Second Intifada.

Shikaki reminded us that two equivalent prerequisites are in place today: the collapse of U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry’s peace efforts and the war in Gaza, perceived by the Palestinians as a Hamas victory.

According to Shikaki’s recent polls, more than 80 percent of Palestinians believe that Israel aims to harm the Muslim sites on Temple Mount and that this “extreme worry about Israel’s agenda for al Haram al Sharif drives greater support for violence.”

The Israeli leadership should be taking action to dismantle this ticking bomb. The way to do it is to use the Arab League peace initiative of 2002 to initiate a regional tie-up with Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and others who are worried by Islamic State and Iran. Together, we could lead the Palestinians — by persuasion or coercion — toward reconciliation with Israel.

Alas, on the same day that Shikaki spoke at the Press Club, the Israel Democracy Institute issued a survey showing that a majority of Israelis has lost confidence in its political leaders. Perhaps the coming elections will produce a leadership that will be able to look at Shikaki’s findings not only as threats but also as opportunities.

Originally published in The Jewish Chronicle Online.

Uri Dromi was spokesman for the Rabin and Peres governments (1992-96).

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy