Las Vegas Sun

April 24, 2014

Currently: 59° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

environment:

Will the Sierra forests ever recover from the Rim fire?

Image

Jae C. Hong / AP

A burned SUV sits in front of a campground destroyed by the Rim Fire near Yosemite National Park, Calif., on Monday, Aug. 26, 2013. Crews working to contain one of California’s largest-ever wildfires gained some ground Monday against the flames threatening San Francisco’s water supply, several towns near Yosemite National Park and historic giant sequoias.

Yosemite Wildfire

In this Friday, Aug. 30, 2013 photo provided by the U.S. Forest Service, firefighters, right, watch over a burn operation on the southern flank of the Rim Fire near Yosemite National Park in California. The wildfire burning in and around Yosemite National Park has become the fourth-largest conflagration in California history. Launch slideshow »
Click to enlarge photo

Yosemite Rim Fire Map

FRESNO, Calif. — California’s biggest wildfire was just a 40-acre canyon blaze west of Yosemite National Park on Aug. 17. In just a few days, the Rim fire grew into a monster, menacing foothill communities and incinerating landscape with 200-foot flames burning at 1,200 degrees.

Motorists 100 miles away near Sacramento saw ash-filled clouds billowing thousands of feet high, as if a volcano had erupted. The still-growing Rim fire footprint is now more than two-thirds the size of Los Angeles and burning into state history — one of the five biggest fires on record.

What happened to that 40-acre fire at the Rim of the World, a peaceful overlook at the Tuolumne River canyon in the Stanislaus National Forest?

Federal scientists say the fire hit overdrive when it moved from the scar of an old fire into overgrown forest that had not burned in a century. The thick forest made the Rim fire historic.

By Friday, it had expanded to 246,350 acres. Fighting it has cost taxpayers $81 million so far. It will be weeks before it is contained.

Experts are saying the ecosystem damage is huge. In a terrifying whoosh, the Rim fire changed the forest for at least a generation and maybe a lot longer.

As the climate changes and more fire takes place, there is a chance big fire-resistant trees might not recover. Fields of flammable shrubs might be all that is left in some places, fire ecologists say.

Further, they say much of the Sierra’s 25 million acres is overgrown and primed for these kinds of large, hot wildfires.

Someday, many parts of the Sierra may resemble Southern California mountains where evergreen shrublands dominate the landscape, said Hugh Safford, regional ecologist for the Forest Service’s Pacific Southwest Region and research associate at the University of California, Davis.

“If you’ve seen those mountains, you know how different they are from the Sierra,” he said. “That’s the kind of change I’m talking about.”

The key is the increase of big fires, which has been documented as the climate has warmed in the past two decades, ecologists said. These blazes quickly torch acres of vegetation.

“A fire like this will kill a third to half of the forest it burns through,” said Malcolm North, research scientist for the U.S. Forest Service and forest ecology professor at UC Davis. “It is devastating.”

One reason the Sierra’s forests became overgrown was a flawed federal policy. Many decades ago, before fire’s role was understood, federal authorities snuffed out all fires. The practice interrupted the frequent, low-intensity fires that kept the forest healthy in the past.

Fire suppression must continue to protect communities such as Groveland in the Rim fire, but there are some hard facts to face, North said.

Federal land managers are trying to thin the forest with controlled fires as well as cutting and clearing heavily forested areas. But there’s simply too much forest that needs thinning.

“We’ve gotten ourselves in a really big hole,” he said. “We’re not going to dig our way out the way we’re doing it now.”

The problem is compounded by waves of nitrogen from some of the nation’s worst ozone air pollution in the San Joaquin Valley. It amounts to a mega-dose of fertilizer wafting into the Sierra’s western slope.

The situation makes fire authorities nervous every summer, particularly this year after two dry winters. The massive Rim fire probably will burn until storms hit in autumn.

Next year, kayakers will see the devastation as they glide down the Tuolumne, said Safford. He said scientists won’t know the extent of the damage until they investigate after the smoke clears, but there is little doubt about what they will find.

“The Tuolumne River canyon will be fundamentally different over the next 50 years,” Safford said.

The fire recovery will be dominated by shrub species, such as chaparral, which is highly flammable, he said. More chaparral also will be apparent in Yosemite, where the fire has burned more than 40,000 acres.

The trees should eventually return, said Yosemite-area scientist Jan van Wagtendonk, research forester emeritus with the U.S. Geological Survey’s Western Ecological Center.

“But if another fire burns through, it goes right back to chaparral,” he said. “That has happened already in some places.”

No one knows for sure what will happen after the Rim fire and throughout the Sierra. Fire recovery is sometimes debated passionately among the experts. People on social media like to talk about it, too.

During the Rim fire, one conversation on Twitter featured the strong recovery of Yellowstone National Park and surrounding areas from the 1.2 million-acre fire in 1988. If Yellowstone recovered, why wouldn’t the Stanislaus National Forest?

Safford said it is a mistake to compare the Stanislaus in the Sierra Nevada to Yellowstone in the Rocky Mountains. Yellowstone’s lodgepole pine forest developed in much wetter conditions — there are storms year-round, he said.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy