Las Vegas Sun

January 30, 2015

Currently: 54° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account


Inequity in state’s spending on roads is a joke


Courtesy Julie Duewel / Nevada Department of Transportation

Traffic is seen Jan. 13, 2011, on Interstate 15 in a construction zone for the Interstate 15 South Design-Build South Project.

Another view?

View more of the Las Vegas Sun's opinion section:

Editorials - the Sun's viewpoint.

Columnists - local and syndicated writers.

Letters to the editor - readers' views.

Have your own opinion? Write a letter to the editor.

Connecting the dots in Carson City is a fool’s errand. Enter the fool.

Sunday, I wrote about Senate Bill 322, which Sen. Debbie Smith, D-Sparks, has bottled up in her committee despite a previous unanimous vote — that’s Democrats and Republicans — to move it to the floor for passage. What could possibly be the reason she is doing this, and, more importantly, what could possibly be the reason Democratic leaders in the Senate and Assembly, both Southern Nevadans, are allowing this to happen?

The answer may be in the answer to the following question: What will happen in Nevada if SB322 becomes law?

SB322 would change the governance structure of the state Transportation Department to add actual transportation experts and provide greater representation for the entire state.

The Transportation Department is governed now by political representatives that favor Northern Nevada’s 700,000 residents versus the more than 2 million people living south of Tonopah. Because of that, the funding formulas for federal dollars coming into Nevada for transportation projects get divvied up in favor of Northern Nevada.

Clark County, which generates about 80 percent of the state’s gas tax, received only 35 percent of the federal formula-based funding for major transportation projects begun from 2006 to 2009. Had the funding matched the population, Clark County would have received nearly $1 billion. Instead, it received less than half of that.

But that’s the way it works in Nevada. Look at how federal money is spent here. In 2010, Washoe County — Reno — received $1,664 per person from the federal government while those of us in Clark County, which is the economic engine for this state, received $772 per person, a stunning difference of $892 per person. If the numbers had been reversed and Southern Nevada got what Washoe County received, it would have meant something close to $1.75 billion in federal money for Clark County!

Do you have any idea what that means? We could build the Las Vegas Beltway every year! We could build the freeway from Arizona to Nevada, linking our 2 million people in Southern Nevada with Arizona’s 4.4 million folks. Do you have a clue what kind of commerce would follow that construction? How many jobs that would create in Southern Nevada?

The rest of that answer is what would happen to the north, what they wouldn’t get if we got our fair share.

We keep hearing about beautiful freeways built between Reno and Carson City — where there is hardly any traffic — while any such thought of road construction in Clark County automatically comes with a toll road suggestion as a way to pay for it. Are you serious?

Wasn’t it the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors Authority that had to kick in $600 million of local money for improvements to Interstate 15? We could have used federal funds had the governance structure in SB322 been in place.


Our governor, Brian Sandoval, is letting, perhaps even encouraging, Northern Nevada legislators such as Debbie Smith to block a bill that would bring fundamental fairness to the way federal dollars are cut up once they get to Nevada.

It shouldn’t go unnoticed that every dollar that we can free up for new and better roads in Southern Nevada has a multiplier effect on the kinds of business that will open and the jobs that will be created. The more jobs, the better the economy. And the more federal dollars that we can spend on interstate commerce, the more local dollars we will have to spend on education.

Speaking of education, why, for example, is there even a debate about the incredible value that the young teachers from Teach For America bring to Nevada? And yet, there is. So much so that the teachers who have been proven over and over again to positively affect the lives of at-risk students are in jeopardy of being cut out or severely cut back from their vital mission in Nevada.

Lawmakers are arguing over a measly few million dollars while they have an easy fix in the palm of their hands. I am not suggesting that they fund Teach For America only if they pass SB322. I merely point out how ludicrous it is not to fund Teach For America for millions when they are throwing away billions elsewhere.

There are literally billions of good reasons to pass SB322 and not one in opposition that I can think of.

And even though responsible people don’t need any more examples of what good governance of transportation can do for this state compared with the politically antiquated and harmful system that currently exists, consider this:

The Carson City bypass is under construction while there is no funding for the much-needed Boulder City bypass, which would be part of Interstate 11.

A bypass around Carson City? Have you been there lately? There are 54,000 people living there, and the population shrunk over the past two years. We are building a beltway around the smallest U.S. metro area at an astronomical cost on a per-person per-usage basis.

Meanwhile, the interstate section being contemplated for Boulder City, which will connect more than 6 million people in Arizona and Nevada and all of their commercial transactions, doesn’t have any funding. Unless you consider a toll road. How do decisions like this get made? Wouldn’t they have more efficacy and wouldn’t the taxpayers trust them more if the decisions to build such projects were made by transportation experts instead of experts in all things politics?

Actually, Gov. Sandoval, it would be good politics to create the kind of open government that other states currently enjoy and which took them many decades to perfect. Nevada is still a young state, but we have examples all around us of how to do it right.

Southern Nevada needs your help, Gov. Sandoval. We need your leadership. We need you to lead the Legislature out of the wilderness of the past and toward the road less taken. That would be the road to progress and success. And those would be the roads that a properly governed Transportation Department would build.

Come on, governor, do the right thing.

Brian Greenspun is publisher and editor of the Las Vegas Sun.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 7 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. An awesome example of how just one democrat can stop infrastructure development and kill jobs at the same time.

    This is just another reminder to vote Republican.

  2. None of this would happen if the Clark County delegation voted NOT by party, but by region. We have more than 2/3 of the legislature. If you want Debbie Smith and the governor (whose name I will not mention, and who deserves to be in lower case) to do something, have the Clark County legislators with their 2/3, veto-proof, tax-proof majority vote to close UNR and every state service north of Clark County. Then let's see how fast they compromise. But since Clark County legislators vote party interests instead of constituents' interests, we have no one to blame but ourselves.

  3. Mr. Greenspun is right with one major exception. He shouldn't cast the blame for road funding inequities solely on Governor Sandoval. He should put the blame where it rightly belongs with the state legislature and in particular Senator Debbie Smith, Democrat from Sparks, who tabled SB322.

    Carmine D

  4. Carmine, Mr. Greenspun DOES mention that State Senator Smith has bottled up the bill in her committee despite a unanimous vote. But if governor sandoval (intentionally lower-case) cared about the whole state and weren't just the governor of Reno, he'd fight to get the bill passed.

    Rex, apparently, you stopped reading the column at the reference to Smith, since your beloved Republicans don't want to do anything about this, either. Too bad they care more about their party than their region and constituents.

  5. Mr Green - You are completely correct that if the Clark county delegation voted as a region it would get it resolved very quickly. But you see the Governor really feels he represents the northern Nevada region more. There are so few Republicans here that they can't swing the tide anyway.

    But who put Senator Smith in her position that she could table the bill? Could it be someone from here? Maybe we are our own worst enemy?


    Please write your legislator and tell them:

    No $$ for TFA.

    Our public schools are starving.

    The last thing we need is for Governor Sandoval and Elaine Wynn to siphon off funds for this pet project.

    TFA places people without a full teaching license in our most at-risk schools.

    TFA teachers do not usually last; they are 3 or 4 times the cost as hiring a fully licensed teacher.

    TFA funded several campaigns against Democratic candudates.

    TFA has been used as a union busting tool by CCSD.

    Please contact you legislators ASAP - because TFA is flooding Carson City right NOW!

    No $$ for TFA. No $$ for TFA. No $$ for TFA.

  7. Maybe when this all gets put on a website for consideration by companies considering a move to Nevada the correct action will be taken.

    Though maybe it already has. Our Business Friendly tax system only seems to bring sandwich shops and internet companies in garages to the State. Even Apple only brings their accounting and bookkeeping personnel from California to the State. There is no technically talented labor pool here and with Sandoval's policies that won't change.