Las Vegas Sun

April 20, 2014

Currently: 68° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

The electrician and the embezzler: a cautionary tale

Trusted bookkeeper to be sentenced Thursday for stealing more than $300K from small business

Image

Sam Morris

N.A.C. Electric owner Tom Clift talks about the ways he former accountant embezzled money from his small business May 2, 2013.

Updated Thursday, May 9, 2013 | 11:38 a.m.

Victim of Embezzlement

N.A.C. Electric owner Tom Clift talks about the ways he former accountant embezzled money from his small business May 2, 2013. Launch slideshow »

Sun coverage

A billing statement for an Office Depot credit card helps tell the story of how a trusted bookkeeper bilked a small Las Vegas electrical company out of a six-figure sum.

The expenses listed for a one-month period in 2010 make Tom Clift, owner of N.A.C. Electric Inc., shake his head and cringe. There’s a $36 charge at a nail salon, $52.93 at Best Buy, $24.86 at the Disney Store, $128.61 to Allstate and numerous purchases at Target. And that’s just a sample.

As for actual office supplies, the billing statement offers only one hint at such a purchase: a $111.89 charge at Office Depot.

“If you sit and dissect it a little, you can understand it better,” Clift said recently as he sorted through thick, colored binders filled with bank statements, copies of checks and other financial documents. “It was very sophisticated.”

This is the evidence Clift, 58, and family members compiled and supplied to Metro Police, which led to the arrest of his company’s bookkeeper, 45-year-old Ana Ocegueda. Police and prosecutors say Clift’s story — one of trust, loyalty and perhaps a little naïveté — isn’t unique. The fraud unit at the Clark County District Attorney’s Office receives three to six cases each month that involve thefts greater than $250,000, said Chief Deputy District Attorney Jay P. Raman.

“A lot of these victims are small businesses — mom-and-pop organizations,” Raman said.

The statement accurately describes Clift, a mild-mannered man who started his career as an electrician in high school and then studied to pass a state contractor’s test to open his own electrical company five years ago.

He considered Ocegueda a friend. They worked together at another electrical company in town, so when Clift decided to start his own business, he asked Ocegueda to come along.

“I figured this was a good match,” Clift said. “I’ll do the electrical work and you do the accounting work, and things are good — or so we thought.”

The Metro arrest report details years of deceit in which Ocegueda wrote checks to herself, completed direct deposits to herself, misused company credit cards and wrote fraudulent checks from Clift’s and his wife’s bank accounts. Total damage: $366,844.13.

The Clark County District Attorney’s Office charged Ocegueda with 33 counts of theft and three counts of unlawful acts regarding computers, according to a criminal complaint filed in September 2012. Court documents indicate Ocegueda, married with two children, has remained out of custody on bond.

During Ocegueda's District Court arraignment in December, the prosecution and defense announced a plea agreement. Ocegueda pleaded guilty to two counts of theft — both category B felonies, the second highest felony category. She will be sentenced Thursday morning in District Court.

• • •

Only about 15 percent of the nation’s fraud victims report the crimes to law enforcement, a scenario fueled by victims’ shame, guilt or embarrassment, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

When it comes to large-scale fraud or embezzlement at small businesses, the thief is often an office manager or bookkeeper granted too much trust, Raman said. They tend to be middle-aged employees with some schooling and no criminal history, he said.

“They’re like the aunt that is not really the aunt,” he said. “They’re super involved in the owners’ lives.”

Clift said he and his wife, Janie, didn’t frequently socialize with Ocegueda outside of the office, but they did throw her a $1,000 baby shower and occasionally would grab drinks with her after work.

The work relationship developed trust. Clift relied on Ocegueda to manage the company’s books — he had no idea how to operate the computer accounting program — and inform him of the business' profits or losses, he said.

N.A.C. Electric Inc. always seemed on the brink financially, Clift said. One time he even took out a loan to cover salaries.

“In reality, I was making a lot of money,” he said. “I was doing things right, but it just wasn’t showing.”

Ultimately, Clift's wife unraveled the fraud after she received an invoice with a late notice from a credit card company. She had never used that card.

Several weeks later, Clift said Ocegueda abruptly left the office one day and didn’t return. They met a week later at a restaurant near the 215 Beltway and Flamingo Road, where Clift said Ocegueda confessed to stealing money.

At the time, Clift didn’t realize the scope of the embezzlement.

“I thought we were talking five or 10 grand,” he said.

Clift’s experience, which involved laying off employees and rebuilding his business, should serve as a cautionary tale, said James Beatty, a detective in Metro’s fraud detail.

“Most businesses don’t do a yearly audit,” Beatty said. “I understand the cost behind those can be quite large … but just have someone else look at the books who is not your bookkeeper.”

Many businesses discover fraud when their bookkeeper goes on vacation, he said.

Beatty said Metro investigates all cases of suspected fraud, regardless of dollar amount. Some of the cases — those involving sums in the hundreds of thousands of dollars — can take years to investigate because of the complexity and length of embezzlement, he said.

One high-dollar case Beatty is investigating involves embezzlement that began a decade ago, he said.

“Whenever you start digging, you find more and more,” he said.

Greed and sloppy work tend to out embezzlers, like most criminals, Raman said. A keen eye for detail can eventually uncover the fraud, whether embezzlers are writing themselves checks, misusing corporate credit cards, taking payments from vendors or pocketing cash, he said.

But why do trusted employees risk everything to steal?

Motivation varies by case, but Raman said many people commit fraud to support a gambling habit, drug addiction or simply to pay mounting bills. People who feed embezzled money into local casinos, he said, often operate under this notion: “If I win, I’ll pay it back.”

“It never happens,” he said. “They get deeper and deeper in debt.”

Raman places some blame on society, where people participate in what he calls “willful blindness” — ignoring warning signs when a person’s job and outward signs of wealth don’t seem to add up.

“People assume someone is doing something wrong, but they’re willing to look the other way because they’re benefiting,” Raman said.

• • •

When Ocegueda appears Thursday before Judge Valerie Adair, she could wind up on probation or be led away in handcuffs.

Clift hopes it’s the latter. He’s angry. He said he and his wife fought about the ordeal for six months. They could have paid off their house and vehicles and not had to lay off hard-working employees. Instead, Clift arrives to the office by 5:30 a.m. and leaves 14 hours later.

Clift wants Ocegueda to serve 3 1/2 years in prison. Because of the embezzled funds, those are the extra years Clift will have to work before he'll be able to retire, he said.

As part of the plea agreement, Ocegueda was ordered to pay restitution totaling $366,844.13. But Raman said most fraud victims never recoup all that was stolen, even if a defendant receives probation and, in theory, can work.

“I wish the enforcement mechanisms were better to get the money back,” he said.

Clift said he planned to file a civil lawsuit against Ocegueda after her sentencing, which he will attend. Clift and his wife mostly just want to know why she betrayed them.

He doesn’t expect to ever fully know that answer, so Clift said he will settle for this: “I want to see the handcuffs go on and her walking out the back door, not the front door.”

CORRECTION: This version corrects the number of Ocegueda's children, which was incorrectly reported in court documents. | (May 9, 2013)

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 6 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Long ago, someone told me, "the only ones who can cheat you are those you trust." Words I never forgot. Putting "some blame on society" is a bunch of "progressive" apcray. Like we must be vigilant in crossing a street, we must be vigilant about our own finances, but never, ever, take any of the "blame" for what crooks, liars and thieves do. The "blame" squarely belongs on the embezzler; no one else.

  2. Something similar happened to me about 10 years ago. Over a 4 year period my bookkeeper had embezzeled about $80,000.

    When you own a businees that has hundreds of thousands of dollars coming in and going out each month, it's tough to locate every nickle sometimes. It was a trusted "family like" employee that did the deed. She relied on the trust factor to never be thoroughly audited.

    In the end I found out that I had bought her a car and paid for her boob job just to name a few. What a fool I was.

  3. My bookkeeper would use her personal Visa to pay for thousands of dollars of personal items each month. She would then write a company check, sign it (my biggest mistake) then make the Quickbooks entry something business related. Even though the check was actually written and mailed to Visa, the Quickbooks entry would read Home Depot or something similar and be applied to a specific job. At the time I literally had a couple hundred thousand going in and out each month and wrote about 200-250 checks monthly.

    When the bank statements came, they had copies of about 50 checks per page, each shrunk down and barely visible so it wasn't until I literally used a magnifying glass to discover the fraud.

    This was the 2001-2003 era. Now I check everything online everyday, and the only signers on the accounts are myself and my son.

  4. Every business owner needs to read Frank Abagnale's book "The Art of the Steal". It has a lot of good information that applies to a lot of businesses.

    One of his points is to not trust the employee who never takes vacation or a day off. Often they need to be at work everyday to maintain their scam because if someone comes in to sub their scam is over. I bet this bookkeeper was like that.

  5. The theft of funds and breach of trust are bad enough. But my blood really starts to steam when you see what these scumbags did with the money. Filled their apartments full of crap they couldnt afford and dont deserve. No doubt they are renters. Even if they scammed country wide, misrepresented their income and debt load and bought a house in north lv.

  6. Not unique at all. Some think that if you can find a bookkeeper or accountant who will help you avoid IRS, that that person is helping you. I know of numerous cases where the trusted "office manager" pocketed the withheld and matching payroll taxes and the businesses/owners got to pay them again with penalties and interest. And I recall the Red Foxx and similar stories where celebrities have "managers" to deal with investing their income only to find out they invested in secreting the funds to hidden accounts leaving the celebs with back taxes and no assets.