Analysis:

Bern’s-Eye View: Commish doubtful all eligible league teams will make a bowl

UNLV or San Jose State would be the likely team left out of a postseason berth. Also, we hand out all-league honors

Image

Sam Morris / Las Vegas Sun

A UNLV fan holds up a sign reading “We Want ‘Bama” during their Mountain West Conference game against San Diego State Saturday, Nov. 30, 2013 at Sam Boyd Stadium.

UNLV vs. San Diego State: Nov. 30, 2013

UNLV defensive back Mike Horsey and head coach Bobby Hauck chest bump after the defense stopped San Diego State during their Mountain West Conference game Saturday, Nov. 30, 2013 at Sam Boyd Stadium. UNLV won 45-19. Launch slideshow »

Mountain West Commissioner Craig Thompson isn’t optimistic that all seven of the league’s bowl-eligible football teams will play in a bowl game.

“I don’t think it will happen,” Thompson said this afternoon on a conference call.

The league has six bowl tie-ins, more than ever before, but it also has more teams eligible than ever before. In its first season with 12 teams, seven of them made it to at least 6-6 thanks to San Jose State’s 62-52 upset against Fresno State. That game set off a domino effect that cost every team in the league a cut of the Bulldogs’ potential BCS payout money and will likely leave one team, maybe even the Spartans, with no game to play in.

“This is not the year to have extra bowl eligible teams,” Thompson said. “In all reality, one is probably not going to be playing in a bowl game.”

The problem isn’t just that the Mountain West has more eligible teams than normal, so does the rest of the country. The last three seasons there have been 72 bowl eligible teams for 70 spots. This season there are still 70 slots for teams, but there are already 77 eligible teams with the chance for three more to get there this weekend.

Thompson acknowledged that there’s interest in moving Boise State to a bowl outside of the Mountain West’s six, but that requires one of those games with a spot to fill to select the Broncos over a field that includes three extra ACC teams and two extra Pac-12 squads.

Click to enlarge photo

Mountain West Conference Commissioner Craig Thompson testifyies before the House Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection Subcommittee hearing on the football Bowl Championship Series on Capitol Hill in Washington on May 1, 2009.

If Boise State doesn’t move to one of those national bowls, then a Mountain West team is all but assured to be left out. That would most likely be either UNLV (7-5) or San Jose State (6-6). Bowl directors aren’t required to pick based on record.

“Seven wins are more than six wins, but those are decisions the bowls will have to make,” Thompson said.

He said the bowls factor in things like past experience — and attendance at those previous games — plus geography and other factors. UNLV and Colorado State (7-6) are the only eligible teams that didn’t play in a bowl game last season.

Assuming Boise State stays in the Mountain West’s games, the decision will come down to four teams for three games — the New Mexico, Hawaii and Famous Idaho Potato bowls. All three games, plus the Las Vegas and Armed Forces bowls, are owned by ESPN Regional Television, meaning that group will work with the individual bowl directors to make their most desired matchups.

Conversations will continue throughout the week but the eligible teams may not get a final answer until this weekend.

All-Mountain West

The regular season is over and the postseason hasn’t started, which means it must be awards season. Next Tuesday the Mountain West will release the all-conference teams voted on my media and coaches.

Before the official word comes down, here’s a look at my ballot. I’ve included some notes when appropriate.

Offensive Player of the Year — Derek Carr, QB, Fresno State

• Easy choice here. It’s not Carr’s fault his defense is awful and the numbers are stunning: 405.6 passing yards per game, 70.3 completion percentage and 45 touchdowns against five interceptions.

Defensive Player of the Year — Shaquil Barrett, LB, Colorado State

• UNLV didn’t play Colorado State, so I didn’t see much of Barrett this season, but I do know he lived in the backfield. Twelve sacks, 20.5 tackles for loss and three forced fumbles.

Coach of the Year — Matt Wells, Utah State

• I think UNLV’s Bobby Hauck will get some votes here, and maybe he’ll even win it. I’m not sure how voters will judge the Rebels’ turnaround vs. a first-year coach in his team’s first season in a new league overcoming a loss to a Heisman-candidate quarterback to become maybe the best team in the league. To me, though, this is Wells’ award.

Special Teams Player of the Year — Carlos Wiggins, RS, New Mexico

• Three kick return touchdowns and a 29.6 yards per return average. Enough said.

Freshman of the Year — Darrell Garretson, QB, Utah State

• Votes for this one may be spread around to a few guys, including to Canyon Springs High grad Donnel Pumphrey at San Diego State, but to me Garretson taking over for Chuckie Keeton and performing well in that role is the most impressive freshman performance this season.

OFFENSE

QUARTERBACK			TIGHT END

Derek Carr, Fresno State	Kivon Cartwright, Colorado State

David Fales, San Jose State	Crockett Gillmore, Colorado State

 

RUNNING BACK			OFFENSIVE LINE

Kapri Bibbs, Colorado State	Austin Wentworth, Fresno State

Tim Cornett, UNLV		Weston Richburg, Colorado State

Jay Ajayi, Boise State		Michael Husar, Air Force

Kasey Carrier, New Mexico	LaMar Bratton, New Mexico

				Tyler Larsen, Utah State

WIDE RECEIVER			Joel Bitonio, UNR

Davante Adams, Fresno State	Brett Boyko, UNLV

Devante Davis, UNLV		Terry Poole, San Diego State

Chandler Jones, San Jose State	Jamie Markosian, Utah State

Brandon Wimberly, UNR		Matt Paradis, Boise State

• I thought for a long time about giving UNLV’s Caleb Herring my vote as the second-best quarterback in the league. David Fales’ numbers are far superior except that Herring has only five interceptions to Fales’ 13. In the end I couldn’t do it but I wouldn’t be surprised if Herring gets a couple of votes.

• Sports information directors really earned their money in the biography descriptions of the offensive linemen. Writers don’t see much if any game film and don’t have the same understanding of what makes a great offensive guard compared to what a coach can see, so we rely on the offensive line descriptions to help us out.

DEFENSE

DEFENSIVE LINE			LINEBACKER

Demarcus Lawrence, Boise State	Shaquil Barrett, Colorado State

Brock Hekking, UNR		Keith Smith, San Jose State

Eddie Yarbrough, Wyoming	Jake Doughty, Utah State

Brett Bowers, New Mexico	Jordan Stanton, Wyoming

Beau Yap, Hawaii		Max Morgan, Colorado State

AJ Pataili’i, Utah State	Zach Vigil, Utah State

Ricky Tjong-A-Tjoe, Boise State

Mark Garrick, UNLV PLACEKICKER

				Jared Roberts, Colorado State

DEFENSIVE BACK			Austin Lopez, San Jose State

Bene Benwikere, San Jose State

Shaq Bell, Colorado State	PUNTER

Donte Deayon, Boise State	Ben Skaer, New Mexico

Derron Smith, Fresno State	Chase Tenpenny, UNR

Marqueston Huff, Wyoming

Nevin Lawson, Utah State	RETURN SPECIALIST

J.J. Whittaker, San Diego State	Carlos Wiggins, New Mexico

Frank Crawford, UNLV		Isaiah Burse, Fresno State

Taylor Bern can be reached at 948-7844 or [email protected]. Follow Taylor on Twitter at twitter.com/taylorbern.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy