Las Vegas Sun

January 29, 2015

Currently: 55° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

In era of stagnant growth, school overcrowding baffles parents


Sam Morris

Erica Gil and her children, from left, Alexa, Madison, Ryan and Justin, are seen in their home Tuesday, Jan. 17, 2012. The Gil’s, who purchased their home based on the school district, are in danger of having their school district rezoned.

Updated Wednesday, Jan. 18, 2012 | 3:03 a.m.

CCSD Rezoning

Students make their way to buses after classes at Del Webb Middle School Tuesday, Jan. 17, 2012. Launch slideshow »

Every weekday morning Tiffany Leard walks 10 minutes from her Henderson home to Del Webb Middle School located less than a mile away.

Next year, the 11-year-old sixth-grader might be bussed more than three miles away to Bob Miller Middle School if her neighborhood is rezoned under a Clark County School District proposal to alleviate overcrowding at Del Webb.

The attendance zone proposal baffles Tiffany’s father, Kelley Leard, who moved his family from Summerlin to Henderson eight years ago specifically for the area schools — ranked among the best in the valley. Never did he fathom his house — located in the housing development just next to Del Webb — would be rezoned to any other school.

“It’s just nuts. It doesn’t make any sense,” the real estate agent said. “How could you zone us out of these schools when they’re just down the street. You’re either just messing with the kids or not planning well enough. Either way, they’re screwing up our lives.”

Of all the hot-button issues facing a school district, only a few things are more contentious than redrawing attendance zone boundaries and reassigning students to a different campus. Yet it’s a nightmarish exercise that the School District engages in annually, even as student enrollment districtwide has stabilized in recent years.

During the boom era, when the Las Vegas Valley was the fastest-growing region in the nation, neighborhoods were rezoned regularly as new schools were built.

At its peak, the School District was opening a school every month, shuffling thousands of students around to bright, shiny campuses.

With the economic downturn, student population growth is at a plateau districtwide. Las Vegans who were able to upgrade to larger homes in the past were now stuck in underwater homes and outsiders no longer wished to move to the economically beleaguered city.

However, there are still pockets of growth in certain areas — notably in the south and southwest valley as some families move into more affordable or foreclosed homes. Consequently, there are some schools with lots of empty seats and others that are jam-packed with so many students that there aren’t enough lockers or textbooks to go around.

Del Webb is one of the latter schools. Built seven years ago, the Anthem middle school was designed to hold a maximum of 1,700 students. The school is currently 12 percent over capacity, and is expecting an influx of at least 100 more students next year from overcrowded elementary schools. Del Webb’s projected student count next year will be 1,926 — some Clark County high schools will have fewer students.

Hallways are so crowded at Del Webb that signs and markers have been posted to direct the massive flow of bodies during passing periods. Students — at a ratio of 35 to one teacher — cram into small classrooms. They share lockers and rely on online textbooks because there aren’t enough for each student.

Nearly two-dozen buses serve the school, lining up like ducks in the back parking lot to receive students when school lets out. Nearby, eight portable classrooms take over part of the staff parking lot.

Principal Paula Naegle says she sympathizes with parents like Leard, but doesn’t know how she will accommodate all the students enrolling at Del Webb next year. The area is hilly, making it impossible to erect more portable classrooms on the school grounds — unless they do away with the staff parking lot altogether.

“I think we’ll have to bus our teachers in,” Naegle said, half-jokingly before turning more somber. “At what point does (overcrowding) become not optimal for learning? And when do you make that tough decision to disrupt families and students?”

Rick Baldwin, the director of the district’s demographics and zoning department, has wrestled with these questions for the past 12 years. His job requires a combination of clairvoyance and careful planning as he tries to figure out solutions to fine-tune enrollment levels to equilibrium across the valley.

There are plenty of seats available for all the students — in fact, middle schools are under capacity by 14 percent districtwide, Baldwin said.

However, the empty seats aren’t in all the right places. Not all the students zoned for a school attend it with the proliferation of open enrollment, magnet and charter school options. Complicating matters is Las Vegas’ notoriously transient community: 30 percent of the 308,000 Clark County students change schools each year.

“It’s a balancing act,” Baldwin said of his rezoning efforts over the years. “We take no pleasure in doing this. I would like to be able to make everyone happy, but I don’t think that’s feasible. I don’t have a crystal ball.”

The School District can’t necessarily build new schools in overcrowded areas either, Baldwin said. The district doesn’t have the funding capacity to issue the bonds necessary to launch a new capital plan, and won’t be able to until at least 2016. Without new schools in the foreseeable future, the district is forced to move excess students among existing schools.

Baldwin, who has rezoned his own children in the past, has been tasked this year with drafting rezoning proposals for three areas in the valley with overcrowded middle schools. If approved by the School Board next month, these new attendance zones would go into effect for the 2012-13 school year.

More than 100 parents packed a public input meeting last week at Silverado High School to voice their concerns about rezoning Henderson middle schools, likely the most contentious of the three rezoning areas this year.

The district’s first proposal for the area would move nearly 800 students at five middle schools: Greenspun, Miller, Schofield, Silvestri and Del Webb. The second proposal would move just under 500 students at three schools. For the families and students being affected by the rezoning proposals, the matter was one fraught with tension and emotions.

Some parents were seemingly fed up with being rezoned several times over the past few years. One parent who lived in Henderson’s “Chimney” area was upset her child had attended four schools in the past five years due to rezoning.

Other parents, like Erica Gil, were frustrated their children would be uprooted from the schools she had spent six months researching before moving into the neighborhood. Gil’s daughter Madison, 13, is a seventh grader at Greenspun who might have to attend Schofield for her final year of middle school next fall.

Over the past two years, Madison has built strong relationships with friends and teachers at Greenspun, which Erica Gil is adamant is a better school and fit for Madison.

“I’m angry and upset we’re being force-fed something that will greatly impact our lives,” Erica Gil said. “It’s very traumatic to be ripped from your school. If you have to constantly rebuild your relationships, it’s not good for their psyche.”

“I just want to be with my friends,” Madison said. “I don’t know anyone at Schofield.”

At the Attendance Zone Advisory Commission meeting on Wednesday, committee members reflected on the public input sessions. (The 11-member committee was formed in 1994 to address rezoning issues amid the largest influx of students the region had ever seen.)

After a series of back and forth discussions about the merits of each proposal, the committee voted 6-1 to recommend that the School Board adopt the second proposal for the Henderson area, arguing it would affect the least number of students. They decided to implement "phasing," or grandfathering current students so they would not be affected by the rezoning next year. The School Board meets Feb. 28 to make its final decision.

“Del Webb is overcrowded,” said committee member Leigh Dunn. “Doing nothing is not an option.”

Leard and Gil can breathe a little easier since their children won’t be affected under the second proposal. But as the student population continues to ebb and flow among existing schools, families might find themselves back at the rezoning maps again – even if they live right next to a school, Leard said.

His daughter Tiffany was rezoned at the elementary school level a few years ago, Leard said. There's no guarantee his neighborhood is safe from rezoning in the future, he said.

“It doesn't make any sense. We’re not going through the growth anymore,” said Leard, who growing up in Ohio said rezoning was unheard of. “So, why do we have to come back and do this again and again, uprooting kids and changing lives?”

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 3 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Are there no middle schools in the areas from which students are daily bussed to Del Webb? If not, why not? It seems that if the students are bussed from more established areas of the valley, then there should already be middle schools in those areas. If new schools were opening at a rate of one new school per month for years, there should be seats all over the valley. The article states that the school was built to hold 1,700 students but that enrollment was about 12% over that projection, or at about 2,000 students. If that is the case, stop busing that 12% to that school. That will solve the overcrowding problem at that school. In addition, I'm told that those school buses hold about 60 students each. If so, 1,200 of the 2,000 students are being delivered to the school each day. That leads me to think that a school built for 1,700 students in their "home" area only holds about 800 students from that "home" area. Who was the analyst who determined the need for the school before it was built? Why doesn't the CCUSD build two-level schools? Nearly all the schools which teach kindergarten through 8th grade that I regularly drive by are single-story schools. One would think that the economy of scale in building a two story school building that would hold twice as many students at a construction cost that is much, much less than the price of land and construction for another single-story school makes sense. But then, I'm not a school board trustee nor am I an analyst for the school district.

  2. Start with enforcing the zoning boundaries you have. I see it every morning-parents dropping their kids off at bus stops that they don't live near or driving across boundaries zones to the schools they live 30 minutes away from. Once you do that, then and only then should you reconsider rezoning and open enrollment.

  3. Seriously? Why would we consider re-zoning the neighborhood next door to the school instead of the areas that require buses to get the kids to school. It makes me wonder how much unnecessary busing goes on in the district.