Las Vegas Sun

January 26, 2015

Currently: 66° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account


The next offer, she won’t refuse

Auction of ‘Godfather’ screenplay will fetch thousands of dollars for Catholic Charities after ‘Pawn Stars’ offer was rejected


Christopher DeVargas

Diane Hutton, director of retail operations for Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada, shows an authentic leather-bound script of “The Godfather.” This rare screenplay was found among thousands of books donated to the organization.

Godfather Script

A script from the movie Launch slideshow »

Last summer, Diane Hutton was offered $500 by the fellows on the cable TV show “Pawn Stars” for a leather-bound copy of the screenplay for the blockbuster 1972 movie “The Godfather.”

She thought she could do better, and turned them down.

Good move.

Thanks in part to the resulting publicity from Hutton’s TV appearance, bidding on the screenplay, signed by the producer, is now up to $7,500. And it may fetch even more money for Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada, where Hutton works, by the time the gavel drops Thursday during the organization’s Heart of Hope Award luncheon at the Mirage.

Today is the last day to buy tickets for the event, but if you want to make a bid for the screenplay, no worries: it can be done online until 11:30 a.m. Thursday. The auction website posts the latest bids.

If someone collects Hollywood memorabilia, this would make a dandy addition: “The Godfather” won three Academy Awards — best picture, best actor (Marlon Brando, a no-show at the awards show) and best adapted screenplay (Mario Puzo and Francis Ford Coppola).

It’s a copy of that screenplay you could take home and put on your coffee table.

How the screenplay ended up at the Catholic Charities’ donation warehouse remains something of a mystery. It might have been purposely donated, or unwittingly dropped off along with other donations by the previous owner, whoever that might have been.

Hutton, manager of warehouse operations for Catholic Charities, remembers the day the screenplay was discovered. She was giving instructions to an employee about how to sort through boxes of donated books, and what to look for that might make one more valuable than another.

Inscriptions and autographs, she said, can be huge bonuses.

“Like this one?” the worker asked later, handing her the screenplay for “The Godfather.” Inscribed on the leather cover was the name Robert Evans, who headed production at Paramount Studios at the time.

The inscription read, “Bob — It cost me a lot ... but there’s one thing that I got ... ulcers — Thanks — Al.”

Because Al Pacino starred in the movie, it was thought it was his signature. To authenticate it, Hutton took the screenplay to Gold & Silver Pawn, where “Pawn Stars” is filmed for the History Channel.

The show brought in a signature authenticator, who said it was Pacino’s. But later, after news of the screenplay circulated, Al Ruddy, the movie’s producer, contacted Catholic Charities and said he wrote the note. And that made sense; Ruddy was the one spending the money and getting the ulcers.

(The signature authenticator apologized to Catholic Charities for the bad call and donated $1,000 to the organization.)

About this time, a person claiming to represent Robert Evans called the charity, saying Evans would like it back. But there was no further contact from the man. Ruddy, in the meantime, says he is so thrilled that the screenplay will make money for Catholic Charities that he is throwing in studio photos of the making of the movie and other goodies, and has taped a message congratulating the winning bidder, whoever it will be.

How much will the screenplay make for the charity? Pat Falvey, spokeswoman for the organization, said she expects it will go for more than the latest bid of $7,500. A man who bid $4,000 has indicated he will show up at the event, and there is an indication, Falvey said, that the top bidder would be standing by ready to offer still more money to get the screenplay.

All of this is great fun for the charity, which is taking online bids for four other high-end prizes and is conducting a silent auction on Thursday for 70 other items.

Besides the fundraising effort, the luncheon will recognize John Mowbray of the law firm Fennemore Craig, and Southern Wine and Spirits of Nevada for their support of Catholic Charities.

But it's a sure bet all eyes will be on the auction of the "Godfather" screenplay, which thrills Hutton.

"Who would have thought that teaching a warehouse worker about what to look for in discarded books would have led to a $7,500 auction bid?" she said. "I'm grateful that 'Pawn Stars' got the ball rolling on this -- and for our supporters who have really stepped up."

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 6 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. There has to be some irony in all this: The Church making money off a work that depicts crime (sin). Ordinarily, I'd think the Church would put something like this on its Index. It wouldn't be the first time the Church consorts with the Devil to make money. Maybe pass it on to a local library, university, whatever. Just don't make money with it. With all due respect, of course.

  2. Sonny1,

    I appreciate your point but I wonder: isn't using the devil's money -- if that's how we want to characterize this, for sake of discussion -- to help feed the hungry and shelter the homeless a righteous and most-appropriate use of the proceeds? The church is consorting with the devil at all. If anything, the devil is probably squirming a little because of how the proceeds are being applied, to help our less fortunate brothers and sisters.

  3. Jesus said, "You are either for me or against me." The Church has to make up its mind. The Church has plenty of other resources to help the poor, needy. It doesn't need this work, one which poses a real conflict of interest for the Church. Jesus drew the line pretty clearly.

  4. if you've got hate in your heart let it out but don't worry so much about a screenplay auction to help those less fortunate.

  5. To think The Godfather only is about violence and condones that leisure shows you don't understand the deeper themes of the movie. I am no expert, but the film is an exploration of the characters motives and the way they react to the consequences of their lifestyle. It is also about the journey of Michael in almost a heart of darkness style and the hell he created for himself. It is as much a morality play than anything.

  6. Jerry, don't presume to tell me what I have in my heart. I suppose if the proceeds of crime help the poor, all to the good. I just don't think the Catholic Church should be the intermediary. Jesus would not approve, either.

    Consider this: The more crime we have, the more money made off it, the more money that goes to helping the poor/needy, the better? I suppose it's the Robin Hood theory. The Church should be no part of it.