Las Vegas Sun

October 23, 2014

Currently: 63° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Courts:

Supreme Court: City can’t euthanize dog that killed child

Dog attacks, kills infant

KSNV coverage of fatal dog attack and interview with grief-stricken father, April 28, 2012.

It’s official: The city of Henderson has been told it can’t euthanize Onion, the dog that killed a Henderson child, until the Nevada Supreme Court decides what to do with the animal.

The high court has issued a two-page order granting the Lexus Project, which wants to place the dog in a Colorado animal sanctuary, a stay of Clark County District Judge Joanna Kishner’s decision in late May.

Kishner had ruled that Lexus didn’t have any ownership rights to the dog and couldn’t take the dog from the city. The Supreme Court had granted a temporary stay on June 1 to keep the city from destroying the animal.

In its latest filing, the Supreme Court prohibited the city “from taking any action against the dog until further order of this court.” The order, issued Friday, also denied the city’s countermotion to dismiss the case.

Chief Justice Michael A. Cherry and Justice Mark Gibbons signed the order while Justice Nancy Saitta dissented to part of it. Saitta said she didn’t think Lexus has met the criteria for granting a stay.

The Supreme Court’s schedule shows that the city and Lexus are expected to lay out their legal arguments about who should get custody of the dog in briefs due on Sept. 24.

Meanwhile, the 120-pound, 6-year-old Mastiff/Rhodesian ridgeback is still being kept in two large connected cages at the Henderson Animal Control and Care Facility.

Onion has been there since April 27, following the deadly attack on Jeremiah Eskew-Skahan, who was at his grandmother’s home to celebrate his first birthday.

The boy reportedly crawled to the dog and pulled on Onion’s fur to stand up, police said. The dog latched onto the boy’s face with his jaws and began shaking him, police said. The boy died at University Medical Center.

After the tragedy, the boy’s grandmother and owner of the dog, Elizabeth Keller, signed papers turning Onion over to a Henderson animal control officer. The city’s vicious dog ordinance calls for the dog to be euthanized, barring a court order, according to a city spokesman.

Lexus is expected to claim the grandmother now wants to turn the dog’s ownership over to Lexus rather than the city. Lexus has offered to provide funds to place and care for the dog in an animal sanctuary in Yoder, Colo., near Denver.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 9 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Thank goodness the Supreme Court had the common sense that Nancy Saitta obviously lacked.

  2. Good. Finally something for the courts that makes sense.

  3. This had to go to the Nevada Supreme Court? What's the problem? The dog killed an infant. It has to be put down, case closed.

  4. I love my dog. But, no matter the circumstances, if she killed a human, relative or not, we would be having dog for dinner. The courts would never be involved. What an incredible waste of time, effort and money. What a tragedy to publicly extend a family's pain for so long by people who weren't even involved in the event.

  5. Dear Honorable Mayor Andy Hafen,

    Please give the dog to Lexus and let them place it in Colorado.

    There is simply no point for the following: "The Supreme Court's schedule shows that the city and Lexus are expected to lay out their legal arguments about who should get custody of the dog in briefs due on Sept. 24."

    Regards
    Purgatory

  6. Parents need to be careful about letting their infants/small children around the family dog, or cat. Pets tend to be jealous, especially if they were the 'baby' first. The dog never showed any aggression until that fateful day and the parents should have thought twice. If your older son/daughter killed their infant sibling.....should they be put down, too?

  7. Kudos to the Supremes. I agree with Davis, but for a different reason. Send Onion to the sanctuary and be done with it.

  8. I'd like to know how much this is costing the tax payer. If a sanctuary wants the dog, why not do the simplest thing and let them take ownership and let the case be closed. It is unfortunate that government becomes this bloated with rules and regulations which ultimately causes the final cost to fall upon the lowly tax payer.

  9. Feed the dog to some horses. After all, fair is fair.