Las Vegas Sun

October 22, 2014

Currently: 83° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Where I Stand:

Social media and social change

Arab Spring will come with enlightenment

I spent the better part of last weekend in Israel. It was a very quick trip to participate in the Jerusalem Film Festival, which is an extraordinary event held in modern facilities overlooking the Old City. The festival, the creation of Lia Van Leer decades ago during some of Israel’s darker days, hosts filmmakers and enthusiasts from around the world in a city where many of Earth’s great stories were first told.

I was there because “Where I Stand: The Hank Greenspun Story” was being shown for the first time in Israel, which, interestingly enough, is one of the most significant beneficiaries of my father’s lifelong commitment to “walking the fine line of justice.”

There were many who questioned my traveling to the Middle East given the turmoil that seems constant and the concern for personal safety that always looms large, especially when the daily news tells of protests, flotillas, rocket attacks and whatever else Israel’s enemies seem comfortable sending its way.

For the record, although I have been to Israel many, many times in my life, the last time I felt the least bit concerned for my safety was in 1962. And that was because I was a young man who just didn’t know any better.

However, given that I am in the news business, I felt it important to ask the question, especially since Jerusalem was as peaceful last weekend as anytime I could remember: Why do we get so nervous over here when the people who live in the middle of the action seem so, well, calm?

The answer is typically Israeli. It comes with a question: Do you see any reason why we should worry? That question, though, led to a more important inquiry about the potential consequences that could result from the Arab uprisings in many of Israel’s neighboring countries and the struggles each of those countries is having with as yet uncertain futures.

I will try to sum up what I learned with the usual warning that it requires looking at that part of the world through the eyes of the people who live there.

By now we are very familiar with the Arab Spring, which is the name used to describe the youthful Arabs who have protested in the streets of many cities in the region demanding that the various forms of tyranny under which they live be set aside in favor of some path toward democracy.

Because of modern communication — Facebook, Twitter and whatever else young people use to talk to one another across boundaries without censorship — those who took to the streets demanding a better life did so, perhaps for the first time, with some real knowledge about what that life might look like. Until then, the people, for the most part, were kept in the dark about the light by which many people around the world illuminate their lives.

When the government can tell ignorant people that they live good and happy lives, they don’t know enough to argue. But when the Internet paints pictures of what happiness and freedom can look like, what individual rights and liberties can be had, and what aspirations can be met, then it is no longer safe for any government to tell its citizens otherwise.

That is what happened in Egypt and that is what has continued to occur throughout the region. But what happens next? The concern in Israel is about what kind of government will replace the ones that have already fallen and will topple in the future.

There are two ways that can go. Backward — more dictatorships that will oppress the people and threaten neighbors — or forward, toward enlightened democratic institutions in which the young people can see progress and the creativity of a people can be unleashed. The genie has long since escaped the bottle, so if the government goes back to the past, those who yearn for freedom will push forward until democracy gets a toehold. It is just a question of time.

If you ask the people in Israel what is the single most difficult obstacle standing in the way of an enlightened future, they will describe it.

The Arab Spring is really a World Spring with young, Internet-educated people who now know about a better life, clamoring for their piece of that future in countries around the globe. But it is difficult, they say, for many Arabs to enjoy a beautiful spring when the people are standing around in their overcoats. Simply put, to enjoy the sunshine of a better tomorrow, those who seek a better future must not bury themselves in the cumbersome vestments of the past.

So what is that burdensome obstacle that may prevent Arab countries from fully becoming part of tomorrow’s better world?

It is called husband. For it is the husbands in Arab society who oppress the women in their lives. Fully 50 percent of much of the Arab world lives under the oppressive thumb of the other half.

How can Arab societies reasonably expect 21st-century countries — which long ago realized that women’s rights such as voting, driving a car, holding a job, working in government and, yes, telling their husbands what to do, were essential ingredients in a democracy — to recognize their own desires for acceptance in a civilized society?

They can’t. For if the mothers are held back, so, too, will be their children. And their children. Somehow that chain must be broken, for that is the way acceptance and opportunity lies. The youthful exuberance we saw in the streets was not exclusively male. Young women, fully empowered and fully partnered with their male counterparts, risked everything for a better tomorrow.

When you ask Israeli men the question about how they see their future unfolding in the midst of the Arab present, that is the kind of answer you get. It is a hopeful one. And, I suspect it is the answer their wives told them to give.

Brian Greenspun is publisher and editor of the Las Vegas Sun.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 3 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. This is extremely promising news to hear! Thank you for taking the time to so ever carefully explain this in a way that all may understand. The media is one of the most powerful leaders in our society which not only informs, but inspires.

    May these youth have the courage to continue moving forward!

  2. This is an accurate and well written piece. I am personally more interested in the Hank Greenspun documentary, which I believe, I watched on PBS a few years ago when it was first shown. I have tried to buy it on home video, but it wan not available a few months ago. I'm hoping it will be released in the U.S. Sometime this year.

    However, this s not a particularly time sensitive piece, and I am surprised that Mr. Greenspun did not use the most read day of the week to write about the life and legacy of Terry Lanni. After a 32 year career that left behind the consolidation of the casino business in Las Vegas and the unequaled in scope City Center, Mr. Lanni left a legacy that has altered the city's landscape for the next century. As a civic leader and media Titan, Mr. Greenspun's comments would have been so important today. At least his current or former employees are doing good work on the story; Steve Friess' excellent interview with Lanni from 2008, which is on The Strip podcast and former Sun editor Jeff Simpson's personal remembrance at TwoWayHardThree.com

  3. Women represent half of society. Half the energy, half the creativity, half the innovation and half the good ideas. If you live in a society that seeks to oppress and hurt women - you will lose half or more of what can move an community forward.

    Allowing women to have a say in government, business, education, and communities is great for everyone - even MEN!