Las Vegas Sun

January 28, 2015

Currently: 58° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Jeb Bush, James Carville stay close to party lines during UNLV debate


Steve Marcus

Political strategist James Carville, left, listens to former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush during a Barrick Lecture Series at UNLV Monday, January 31, 2011. Jon Ralston, center, moderated the discussion.

Carville and Bush at UNLV

Political strategist James Carville speaks during a Barrick Lecture Series with former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush at UNLV Monday, January 31, 2011. Jon Ralston moderated the discussion. Launch slideshow »

Sun Coverage

Republican Jeb Bush, Florida's former two-term governor, and Democrat James Carville, Bill Clinton's former political strategist, debated federal policy, forecast the 2012 elections and traded friendly barbs during a wide-ranging conversation Monday night at UNLV.

Not surprisingly, Carville largely defended the Democratic agenda — namely health care reform and government support — while Bush promoted the typically Republican ideals of deficit reduction and less government intervention.

Even so, Bush broke from party lines to admonish Republicans for failing to come up with a better health care solution, and Carville appeared to entertain the idea of tax cuts as one prong of a larger plan to re-stimulate the economy.

The conversation, part of UNLV's Barrick Lecture Series and moderated by Sun columnist Jon Ralston, opened with reflections on the 2010 elections in which Republicans took control of the House. Bush described his party's victory as a repudiation of President Obama rather than a validation of the GOP (mentioning Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid's win as a notable exception) and warned that "now is the time for Republicans to step up."

Carville argued that Democrats focused on the wrong message and lost because they failed to convince voters that their policies were working while unemployment rates continued to climb.

"Show me any headline that says '9.5 percent unemployment, incumbent elected,'" Carville said. "The people wanted to spank the president, and they ended up caning him."

Click to enlarge photo

Political strategist James Carville speaks during a Barrick Lecture Series with former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush at UNLV Monday, January 31, 2011. Jon Ralston moderated the discussion.

Carville outlined a favorable future for Obama, and Bush seemed to agree, calling him a "formidable opponent." Bush also noted that Republicans will have to work hard to maintain independent voters' support.

Both speakers took a casual approach to the debate, but at times talked over one another. Carville was seen rolling his eyes on a few occasions.

Bush ribbed Carville as well, but called him a friend and stressed his respect.

"Hell, he beat my dad," Bush joked.

The audience leaned more Republican than Democratic, with Bush receiving the loudest applause. One audience member grew rowdy early in the event, shouting at Carville as he derided Republicans' budget plan.

"The Sharron Angle people are here tonight — no Second Amendment remedies," Carville retorted.

On the subject of education, the speakers kept to party lines, offering recommendations that sounded eerily familiar to the 1,250 people packed in the auditorium.

"Here in Nevada, they are slaughtering education to save everything else," Carville said.

Bush noted that in Florida, he eliminated social promotion for third-graders and added advanced placement classes in poor schools to boost underprivileged and minority students' outcomes.

"Florida's low-income, Hispanic kids do better than California's average, at 50 percent the cost," Bush said.

If the approach sounds familiar, it should. Gov. Brian Sandoval is also proposing doing away with social promotion. Bush served as a mentor to Sandoval during his campaign and will continue to advise the governor on education issues, a Sandoval spokeswoman said.

The biggest chuckle of the night came during a discussion of pension funds. Audience members couldn't contain themselves as Carville — unprompted — mentioned that public employees earn lower salaries than private workers. Loud jeers erupted in the auditorium.

Click to enlarge photo

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush speaks during a Barrick Lecture Series with political strategist James Carville at UNLV Monday, January 31, 2011. Jon Ralston moderated the discussion.

Carville looked slightly confused until Ralston explained that local firefighters have come under attack recently for their salaries and apparent abuse of sick time.

The event ended with questions from the audience. One Bush supporter asked if the former governor's family ties would hurt him during a bid for the White House.

"Since I'm not running, I guess it won't hurt me," Bush said.

Bush is the son of former President George H.W. Bush and the younger brother of former President George W. Bush. He is considered a potential 2016 presidential

candidate but has said he won't run for president in 2012.

Bush said he believes that in time, his brother's legacy will be viewed more favorably.

And while stressing that he has no presidential ambitions (yet), he added: "If I ran for office, I would be a proud younger brother of George W. Bush and a proud son of George H.W. Bush."

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 6 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. I wish I had been there for this. I respect both of these men and I'm sure this report doesn't do either of them justice. (But I admit that I am surprised that Carville didn't know our situation with the firefighters' union.)

  2. The LV Pravda calls Carville a "political strategist." I call him "white trash." I'm sure they had to deodorize the auditorium once he exited!

  3. I wonder if the drug war topic came up? Jeb might have some incite since his daughter got special treatment after her arrest for drugs.

    One law for the ghetto black, another law for the politician's daughter when it comes to drugs.

    Jeb Bush supporter Limbaugh also seems to get a "get out of jail card" from the bigoted Floridah judicial system for his doctor shopping as well.

    I'm glad the civility is alive and well here in the LV Sun. Wasn't too long ago that people in Germany were talking about others "being trash" or carrying TB, Typhus, etc. and comparing them to rats and vermin.

  4. I'm sure Jerry Fink is just as intelligent and successful as James Carville, Right, Jer???

    By the way, Jer... Carville is Cajun.

  5. Shredding education is part of Governor Sandoval's plan to remove over a billion dollars from the state economy and drive even more private business into bankruptcy and people into poverty. That will be the result of removing demand in the form of state workers and contracts from that economy. Why is this so hard to understand for conservatives?

  6. Wasn't two from the elite silver spoon Bush family enough in American politics? Its gonna take 100 years to straighten out the mess "W" made and he wasn't even elected.