Las Vegas Sun

April 17, 2014

Currently: 88° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

WHERE I STAND:

Status quo isn’t good enough anymore

In Nevada as in Egypt, people must demand change from leaders

Hosni Mubarak is gone.

After 30 years as president of Egypt and three decades as a friend and reliable ally of the United States, and after one-third of a century of maintaining peace with Israel and, therefore, a modicum of stability in the volatile Middle East, Mubarak is gone. It is an end of an era.

The question now is what will define the next era? Thousands of cheering and excited Egyptians who filled the streets for 17 days got what they — and, presumably, most Egyptians — wanted. They wanted change, they wanted something different, they wanted Mubarak gone. Under the headline of “Be careful what you ask for,” the Egyptian people — and, for certain, the rest of the Middle East and the world — will have to live with the consequences of the decision Mubarak made to step aside and allow Egypt to chart a course without him. It was a decision that even he finally had to admit was the only reasonable and responsible answer to the challenges that plagued his presidency.

That is often the lesson learned in life. We get to a point at which we know what we are doing is wrong. We know it ain’t working. And we know we can do better. We realize we must change even in the face of some very strong forces arrayed against that change. Those would be the people invested in the status quo. They don’t want change because life is good for them.

There are plenty of others, of course, who aren’t getting what the privileged few are enjoying. They are among the folks in the streets. They want better lives for themselves, for their children and for their children’s children. And they are willing to risk the unknown to get that chance for something better.

That is what we watched on our television sets the past three weeks, and their spontaneous jubilation Friday morning was the culmination of their immediate dreams. We have to keep watching, of course, to see what they — and the world — actually get with this change of mind by Egypt’s leadership.

To keep the whole thing in perspective, the last time Egypt changed presidents, it was the result of an assassin’s bullet. The man who could have transformed Egypt and the Middle East, Anwar Sadat, was gunned down by the forces of the status quo. People who thought war and violence in the Middle East were the only way to preserve a future cut Sadat down at the beginning of his efforts to transform the way his people and Arabs in general did business in the region.

This transition, by comparison, has been peaceful. And that is a major piece of business for Egypt and other Arab countries whose people may yearn for less autocratic regimes.

Is there a lesson in this historic change that the people of Nevada can take to heart? I think so.

It is no secret that our state has been the hardest hit during this depressing recession we have been living through the past three years. We lead the country in foreclosures, unemployment and bankruptcies. Our population decline the past couple of years is nothing short of dramatic. Pick any economic indicator and Nevada is either dead last or too close to the bottom for any kind of comfort.

It is also no secret that in a state that needs jobs, jobs and more jobs, we have done nothing to advance the prospects that the thousands and thousands of people who are still here looking for work will ever get a job. To do that, we have to have businesses that grow or new businesses that will come here. Neither is happening.

In the face of all this (let’s call it the status quo like in Egypt), what is our leadership doing? I wanted to say nothing, but that is not quite true. Our governor, Brian Sandoval, is trying to do something to advance Nevada toward a goal of creating more jobs and a more stable economy. But the way he is doing it is much like Mubarak’s pronouncements to his people who were clamoring for freedom.

Our governor is talking around the edges of the discussion without giving the people the kind of change they really need. Clearly, Egyptians had real issues with their leadership. They wanted freedoms like speech, assembly and press. Simple things. What the people of Nevada want are jobs.

Giving the people of Egypt what they wanted was so much harder for Mubarak than it is for Sandoval to give the people of Nevada what they want. For starters, Mubarak had to give up power and step down as president. That’s a lot to ask! But he did it because, in the end, he knew there were no other reasonable choices.

In Nevada, Sandoval thinks there are reasonable choices when it comes to creating jobs and a better quality of life for Nevadans. But the choice he is opting for is the status quo. That means we will be able to tell people that Nevada is one of the lowest-taxed states in the country. We have held that distinction for decades. Where has it gotten us?

We are at or near the bottom of every list that quantifies the quality of life for our citizens. I don’t care how much people say they don’t want to pay more taxes, they don’t want to be at the bottom of those lists, either.

But let’s stay practical, just like the folks on Cairo’s streets who stayed focused on what they wanted. We want jobs.

It is beyond question that getting more jobs, diversifying our economy to bring those jobs and training our workforce to be able to perform those jobs should be Job One in Nevada. It is also beyond question that education is the single best solution to each of those goals. In the face of that truth, what is our good governor proposing? To cut education at all levels to the point that Nevada will be forever on the bottom rung of any ladder toward the advancement of its people.

Egyptians marching in the street would not accept Mubarak’s efforts to give them lip service while maintaining the status quo. That meant he stayed in power with his hand on all the levers, which meant that nothing would change. Nevadans should not accept the status quo, either. Being the lowest-taxed state means being consigned to last place when we should be among the best this country has to offer.

I realize Nevadans are not going to take to the streets, and I am not suggesting we do so. But I am urging every parent of a child for whom they want the best, every person who wants to have a business, and every young person who likes Nevada but doesn’t like the idea that there is no future here for him or her, to get proactive. Tell your legislators and your governor that the status quo is no good anymore. That lowest taxes equate to lowest levels in all areas of achievement and success. That we can do better.

So here is just one tidbit to consider when you are thinking about how important education is to our economy and our job creation. Although the money spent on education is not the only determinant of how good that education is and, therefore, the prospects for better jobs and a better life, it does provide some indication of the value a state places on it.

Mississippi, Arkansas, Kansas, Utah, New Mexico and Nevada each have populations of 2 million to 3 million people. Think about those states and the quality of their universities in relation to one another. Now look at what each state spends for their higher education.

Mississippi — $1 billion; New Mexico — $931 million; Arkansas — $882 million; Kansas — $753 million; Utah — $687 million; and Nevada — drum roll please — $397 million.

Is it any wonder why we lag way behind practically every other state when it comes to the education of our people? Is it any wonder why so many of our best and brightest citizens leave Nevada for other states for their education and don’t return? Is it any wonder why companies consider our low-tax status and still refuse to move here? The questions go on and on, but the answer stays the same.

We don’t value those things that bring value to Nevadans. Egyptians changed 30 years of autocracy by demanding a better life. And they were willing to take the chance that is what they will get. Why can’t Nevadans garner a fraction of that courage and demand that our leadership change the way we value education in this state?

Why?

Brian Greenspun is publisher and editor of the Las Vegas Sun.

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 13 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Yes...'Status quo gottsta go.'

    Violent street demonstrations and assassinations are not the answer; merely another prelude for a new status quo and another cycle of madness.

    The Greenspun analogy between Egypt and Nevada is valid. 2 trouble spots, both in need of strong leadership and viable, perpetually-sustaining and expanding solutions.

    'Build it and they will come' can either be a field of dreams or a meaningful plan of action.

  2. Egypt is second only to Israel as a recipient of foreign aid. Last year was between $2.1 and $2.5 billion, with $50 billion total over the past 30 years. Two-thirds of that goes to the military, not quality of life.

    Today, Egypt has a failing economy and the Swiss bankers are doing better than ever.

    Our friends? Sure!! for $2.1 billion/year America can find all the dictators it needs to slam the lid down on the country. America would not want a President in office for 30 years, so why is it happy to finance the same for another country? No concern for Democracy, just control and denial.

    Egypt isn't the only example of America's trounce and hold foreign aid policy - it's time to stop feeding police states and Swiss bank accounts and bring the money back home to rebuild America.

  3. Looks like Egypt and Vegas have more in common than just a pyramid.

    All the talk radio nuts, local and national, wanted Mubarak for the most part, so much for liars like Mark Levin, who wrote a book: "liberty and tyranny" ...when the chips we on the line, he was for tyranny.

    Democracy is great as long as people are for what we want.

    I support the: communist-socialist-Muslim brotherhood-George Soros in the basement controlling everything-Michael Moore-conspiracy to takeover the world caliphate.

    I just got off the phone the with the Canary Islands, the Caliphate has reached there and is jumping the Atlantic. The pyramid in Vegas is a sign of Muslim triumphalism...it should be converted to a trapezoid.

  4. I think Mr. Greenspun is pushing the edges with this analogy (and he even recognizes it). Stick with the Mississippi comparisons.

  5. No, Turrialba, "Mr. Greenspun" is comparing the somewhat peaceful overturn of Mubarack to what could happen here.

    Go back and read more slowly (between the cautiously crafted lines and conceptual progression, all the way to the end...'Why?'), Turri.

    Brian knows the difference between angry Egyptians and angry Americans...an angry cat backed into a corner versus a wounded tiger.

  6. Where does Brian get his numbers? In FY 2000 the Nevada State Higher Education budget was $306 million, in FY 2009 it was $1.694 billion. So with ever increasing budgets what have we gotten with our money? Did it help diversify our economy?

    This is what liberals do. They play with the numbers to make us all feel guilty. Like they do with the K-12 numbers. Where the last budget was $6900 operating bidget per pupil but total spending was $11,900 per pupil. Neither budget looks very efficient to me. It's great for the administrators and employees living off money that should be going to the actual educating. How about we move that money to services that help people in a meaningful way. They'd be grateful. Instead Brian wants us to hand over more money to a bureaucracy that is more interested in feeding itself rather than the kids and people they are supposed to be educating.

  7. The Low Tax State (NV) meets the Dumbest State (NV) as measured in percentage of college degrees, meets the worst Medical Care State(NV), Highest Foreclosure Rate State (NV), Highest Unemployment Rate State (NV), and the lows and worst continue to roll.
    Until a progressive Income Tax is implemented, regressive taxes (Sales, Lisc. Plates, User Fees, etc.. are reduced, and industry (Gaming and especially Mining) Pay for their fair share of Nevada Taxes we will continue to be the backwater of the West. Visionary Leadership and Political Will are needed to advance the state. However looking at the current crop of politicians I'm waiting to be impressed. Plan Now, Zone Now, Regulate Now, Stick by your policies unless there is a Great reason for a change (not developer dollars) and never, ever get into this mess again.

  8. Old Bakers Adage:

    'My friend, as we wander through life; as we laugh & cajole...remember just this one thing...

    "Keep your eye on the donut and NOT on the hole.'

    Robert, Ben, guys & gals...you're being flanked by political, tax and legal diversions.

    Corporate cookie monsters are sneaking up on you, creeping in & out of your lives, eating all of your cookies.

    "Impertinence" is shaping up to be this valley's epitaph.

    Brian Greenspun knows this and is trying to get your eye back on the donut with this editorial.

  9. Is it possible for anything of significance, either great or calamitous, to occur without great participation by we the many, even if our greatest participation is a failure to react? If we can't escape participation shouldn't we begin to participate better?
    Who holds more knowledge and power in the nation, the few in government, the few in corporations, the few in our courts, or the many of our citizens? Who recognizes where true power lies?

  10. WHY? Great question and one I have been asking educators and business people since I arrived here 3 years ago. I have been stunned by the lack of basic grammar of the average business person, broker, manager. Amongst a group of local 40 something racket ball players, Joe says "I won Mark today" ... I say you mean "you beat Mark". "No, he insists, he won Mark" and several guys standing around agree with him that he is grammatically correct.
    Back to the central question of WHY? Why don't we as Nevadans value education? I think there are several answers ...

    First, Las Vegas has for the last 40 years been the city you could go to with little or no formal education and still earn very good money in the hospitality or construction industries. In fact the lack of educational criteria for hiring and making good money has almost defined Las Vegas for the past 40 years. So we are talking about parents who arrived here and succeeded without formal education and I suspect they value quality education less than parents in other states.

    Second, Vegas is home to a great deal of foreigners who arrived here also with little education. Teachers tell me they get very little response from parents with respect to supporting their kids studies.

    To believe that our poor education system and lack of technically skilled workers does not impact the development of alternative industries, is very naive. At a bipartisan conference hosted by of the Governor today, technology firms specifically stated that lack of skilled workers in Nevada is a deterrent and one tech firm that did move here, had to import skilled labor from out of state.

    Why would an executive move his management team here so that his and their kids could get the worst education in the nation?

    I think we keep cutting education because we, the public don't value it enough, and because it is the weakest constituency that squawks the least. Therefore it is the path of least resistance for politicians. No lobbying power and no campaign contributions.

    Of course, long term it is costing us dearly.

    There is still federal money available for incubators - incubators on average produce jobs that pay more than double temporary construction jobs and tend to be permanent jobs. We have one asset in our higher educational institutions - they are experts in the gaming industry. Why are they not collaborating with major gaming companies to develop technology and marketing incubators focusing on the gaming industry, new media, social media, online technology and the future migration of their business to the web?

    It will happen sooner or later.

  11. Mark, if you have been here for 3 years, then you must have encountered the ultimate, down-line backlash from poor grammar, language barriers and low quality education...

    ...the silent, dull, listless look in the eyes, accompanied by an unintelligible or complete lack of response.

    ...a comprehension level of about -10 on the number line.

    And attention spans are about as short as the spin of a slot machine and not much longer than a race at the Sports Book.

    But enough about comprehension deficiencies on the executive levels...LOL

  12. And all of this from the Guy who claimed that he used to run to the top od mt Charlston to eatch the mushroom clouds appear.

  13. And all of this from the Guy who claimed that he used to run to the top of mount Charleston to watch the mushroom shaped clouds appear.