Las Vegas Sun

July 23, 2014

Currently: 109° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Law enforcement:

Video of Las Vegas constables draws ire of county officials

Reality TV, Las Vegas constables

People might think of constables as affable public employees whose job mainly is to serve civil documents — such as subpoenas, property liens, court summonses and wage garnishments — and enforce evictions. They’re recognized by state law as “peace officers,” and they carry guns and Tasers, but they rarely take people to jail — and deputy constables get paid based on the number of papers they serve.

The job is more sad than exciting, especially as evictions become commonplace during the economic hell Las Vegas is slogging its way through.

A video producer thought there was enough drama and action with the job to produce a TV series test pilot featuring interviews and ride-along scenes with deputy constables in the Las Vegas Township Constable’s Office, one of a handful in the Las Vegas Valley. It had the look and feel of a home-produced reality TV show.

Constable John Bonaventura posted the video on his personal Web page.

And some of the content is alarming state and county elected officials who have stumbled upon it.

The video, titled “Dec. 15, 2011, Test Pilot Reel for National Reality Show,” opens with a clip from an August report from CBS News about the jobs of Las Vegas Township constables at a time when foreclosures and job losses are epidemic. After the stage is set, the real TV video gives way to the locally produced story, beginning with Lou Toomin, the constable’s public information officer.

“I’m kind of a rabble-rouser,” says Toomin, who carries a gun but whose main job is dealing with the media. “I don’t conform to the spit-and-polish (expletive), the Marine Corps crap. It’s way beyond me. It’s nitpicking (expletive).”

Toomin, who sports a graying ponytail in the video, goes on to describe vehicle stops as “probably the most dangerous thing a cop does.”

Indeed, constables can make traffic stops and can arrest people. As peace officers, state laws grant them the same rights and privileges as Metro Police, Toomin says.

The video shows a deputy constable stopping a motorist for not having his vehicle registered in Nevada. The angry driver is handcuffed and arrested.

Later, the video shows Sgt. Patrick Geary talking about evictions as “not all hugs and kisses; you’ve got to get into people’s (expletive) sometimes.”

“I wait all day long for someone to (expletive) with me,” he says.

The video veers into Geary yelling three times into his cell phone at a property manager: “Do not yell at my employee!”

There’s more, including a scene in which a deputy constable talks about how, after failing three times to serve a document to the owner of a shoe store in Circus Circus, she returned several more times because she liked shopping at the store so much.

After viewing the video, state Assemblywoman Marilyn Kirkpatrick, D-North Las Vegas, said she is considering drafting legislation to rein in some of the activities and practices of the constables. She was particularly disturbed by the deputy constable making a traffic stop and arrest.

“It appears they are going above and beyond what the state expects of them,” Kirkpatrick said, calling what she watched “an embarrassment.”

“I want to clarify what they are doing, what they can do,” she said.

County Commissioner Steve Sisolak, who also has viewed the video, said state law “definitely needs to change.” To address the office locally, he added an item to next week’s commission meeting, asking for a report on the constable’s office.

“It’s the cursing, it’s the arrest, it’s the way the office is portrayed,” Sisolak said. “It looks unprofessional.”

He said he was also troubled by deputy constables pulling over motorists.

Bonaventura is unapologetic about his employees’ conduct — and suggested that if the county launched an investigation into his office, it could open a “can of worms” involving a possible violation of state law on the part of the county relating to its handling his office’s finances.

He bristled at the notion of an elected official “even asking for a report” on another elected official.

“It’s one thing if you’re investigating a county agency like Parks and Rec, but for him to ask for this seems a bit out of his scope of duty,” Bonaventura said.

Of the video, Bonaventura told the Sun the driver shown being arrested had three outstanding warrants.

Bonaventura said deputy constables make an arrest once a month but that before he took over after last fall’s election, the office was arresting 50 people a week for outstanding warrants. His office no longer has a warrants detail, he said.

During a ride-along Wednesday, Geary explained the scene in the video in which he’s yelling into the phone. He said he was yelling at a property manager who, he said, had called one of the clerical staff in the constable’s office and “chewed her out,” leaving her in tears.

Toomin said he never expected the video to be shared with the general public. When he received it a few weeks ago, he took it as “tongue-in-cheek” from the show’s producer because it includes some cursing.

Bonaventura added that “none of us are in favor of the show. It’s going nowhere. We aren’t doing it.”

“That’s why we didn’t run it by the county people, because we didn’t have plans to go forward with it in the first place,” he said.

But the video is out of the bag, and there’s talk in the halls of the county government center about putting the constable’s office under closer scrutiny.

Sisolak said he has several questions about its operation, including the making of traffic stops.

Toomin said the stops are to enforce the state’s Fair Share program. Under that program, people who migrate to Nevada but fail to register their vehicles can be fined up to $1,200, and the public is invited to tattle on violators. The constable’s office gets $100 for each violator it turns in to the Department of Motor Vehicles.

Bonaventura said no one had contacted him as of Thursday afternoon to appear at next week’s commission meeting.

“Frankly, it’s none of their business,” he said of the threatened scrutiny. “I’m the elected official running this office. I’d be happy to give them a crash course or point them to the law because everything we do is pretty much cut and dried from (Nevada Revised Statutes).”

Join the Discussion:

Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

Full comments policy

Previous Discussion: 9 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Holy #&@#!!!...

    Looks like we got us a real-life Reno 911!

    Time to pull the plug on these out-of-control EGO-MANIACS.

  2. Finally!!! A TV show that sheds light on Las Vegas style humanity.

  3. Constables pulling people over for Traffic Stops? This isn't anything new.

    Buffalo between Warm Springs and 95 last spring ALWAYS had a constable involved in a traffic stop every morning. You can always spot them thanks to those silver Ford Escape Hybrids they drive. They also LOVE to hang out on Industrial Road (or Dean Martin, I get so confused since the name change) between Russell and Tropicana. Not unusual at all to see about 3 of them parked there, hidden on the other side of the overpass with a 4th running radar on the south end of the road to catch speeders. Given how the Clark County Building Inspectors have been running around and writing up every hotel in town for building and/or fire violations, I figured the Constables were doing the same thing as a way to justify their jobs as well.

  4. "and the public is invited to tattle on violators."

    I don't know about you folks, but this part really worries me too. Is this the America we want? Be a hero to the state and snitch on your neighbors?

    Shades of Germany 1939.

  5. "Time to pull the plug on these out-of-control EGO-MANIACS."

    "I have never used the phrase "jack-booted thugs" before but....... these goons behave like "jack-booted thugs"

    gmag39, Heretic -- for once I'm on your side with this

    "Constables pulling people over for Traffic Stops? This isn't anything new."

    DMCVegas -- why not? The local school cops are doing it, even though their empowering law clearly puts it out of their jurisdiction.

    "The county and state need to define and enforce the responsibilities of this rouge department."

    homer -- you're suggesting these constables wear to much makeup?

    This town seems to be infested with cop wannabes. I remember seeing Bonaventure's election signs last year and didn't vote for him because of his fascist exhibition. Apparently it's what this county's voters wanted.

    The questions need to be asked and answered -- 1) what's the NRS laws giving constables their badges, and 2) what is it about traffic stops motivating every pseudo-cop to make them?

    Sisolak is definitely on the right track with Bonaventure, who seems to be way too eager to carve out his own brute-force empire here. He needs to be reminded what part of government he works for -- checked and balanced!

    "Fear is the foundation of most governments." - John Adams "Thoughts on Government" (1776)

  6. To my fellow bloggers;

    Needless to say that was not a very flattering video of the workings of our Constables Office. If I were in charge I would definitely edit that video to reflect a more professional and experienced image, especially editing some of the harsh language used. It is a sad part of Law Enforcement to have to evict someone from their home, but it is still the law. As for registration fees on vehicles that has always been a sore point with me, as this state is allowed and authorized to collect fees for vehicles that are supposed to be registered and insured and that are constantly being used on this state's roads. If I can obey the law, then so can they. Just an old veteran cop reflecting,

    Gordon Martines

  7. I'll bet dollars to doughnuts that the Constables have been told by either the State or the county to step up their action to help bring in more revenue.

    Constables, like motorcycle cops, are little more than glorified tax collectors with a gun and a badge.

  8. "If I were in charge I would definitely edit that video to reflect a more professional and experienced image, especially editing some of the harsh language used...As for registration fees on vehicles that has always been a sore point with me, as this state is allowed and authorized to collect fees for vehicles that are supposed to be registered and insured and that are constantly being used on this state's roads."

    GordonM -- I adamantly disagree with you on editing. How would that not be lying to We the people?

    About registration, what exactly is the state's compelling interest in private property used for private purposes on the public right of ways being on any state registry? Like marriage licensing, our ancestors bought into that hoax.

    Both our state and federal governments were Constituted to secure our liberties, not replace them with this police state.

    "I heartily accept the motto, 'That government is best which governs least'; and I should like to see it acted up to more rapidly and systematically." -- Henry David Thoreau 1849 "On the Duty of Civil Disobedience"

  9. "...I'm going to go out on a limb here and say it's most probable that he got arrested for no license, no registration, and no insurance; all being repeated offenses."

    QWERTY -- none of those are actually crimes, regardless of what the law says. Exactly how does being without a license, registration, or insurance harm anyone except government coffers -- and an excuse for the stop and searching the person and vehicle for something else to pin him with?

    "Rightful liberty is unobstructed action according to our will within limits drawn around us by the equal rights of others. I do not add 'within the limits of the law' because law is often but the tyrant's will, and always so when it violates the rights of the individual." -- Thomas Jefferson, letter to Isaac H Tiffany (1819)