From the publisher:
A midsummer night’s stream
Fri, Sep 17, 2010 (3 a.m.)
It had been a long and hot summer, simmering with bitter political divisions and desperation over the economy. But as summers so often do, it was passing too quickly.
There was still time to celebrate the season, which for me is best accomplished on a fishing trip to Alaska with old friends George and John. In Wasilla, we hurriedly piled everything into John’s float plane, got airborne in front of Sarah Palin’s house and headed to the outback in pursuit of salmon.
When we landed, the fish were waiting and our fly rods soon were busy. It wasn’t until we built a campfire that we really had much of a chance to catch up with each other.
Camped in a remote wilderness with friends I see but once a year, talk soon turned to politics. That’s the way things are everywhere these days. Politically charged.
We took our customary positions on the right and left, them holding to a conservative post, and me cast in the stereotyped role of liberal media type. Thanks to the Web and cable television, the boys manage to stay very well-informed in Alaska, and soon we were debating the issues of the day.
Like so many people here, George and John are bothered by the current state of affairs in a number of areas: health care, the economy, the federal bureaucracy, environmental legislation, the proposed ground zero mosque. And, of course, the leadership of President Barack Obama. And that was just the first night’s agenda.
The next day, we again were busy with fish, joined by new visitors in the way of mosquitoes and black flies. They swarmed by the millions, although that is merely a crowd estimate.
That night around the fire, we picked up where we had left off. Somehow, Yucca Mountain came up.
Don’t want a nuclear dump in our state, I said. Naturally, the boys had done a bit of reading on the topic, and our conversation soon became louder.
George said my position seemed unfair, and that Nevada should accept Yucca for the good of the nation. He pointed out that many of Alaska’s land uses are being unnecessarily restricted — against the will of its residents — because environmentalists essentially want to turn the state into a giant national park for tourists.
Alaskans don’t want this, he said. So why should Nevada get off easy? Shouldn’t Nevada take one for the American team?
No, I said. Yucca is just too close to Las Vegas.
Impasse having been reached early in our trip, there was no place to go after this, and after some silence, we turned in for the night.
The next day brought plenty of rain, which meant some relief from the bugs. The fishing was wetter but still good. Around the soggy fire that night, we worked just to keep a flame going and to stay dry, leaving little atmosphere for political engagement.
When the sun returned the next afternoon, fresh legions of mosquitoes greeted its arrival. So did plenty of salmon, passing in schools through the clear waters, all hoping to reproduce in the cold waters upstream.
A large sockeye salmon swam past me, its dark green head attached to a body that had turned bright red in preparation for spawning.
We caught and released pink salmon, the males having morphed into the exaggerated humped backs and hooked jaws you see on Discovery Channel specials. There were large chum salmon, whose spawning cycle was well under way and whose bodies revealed the attendant signs of decay as they lived out their final days.
Finally, on the last couple of days, we encountered the spirited coho salmon, the muscular silver swimmer prized by fly fishermen, which begins its own spawning journey in the early autumn.
The sunshine had finally dried out our personal effects, and the fish had been plentiful. The wilderness had delivered as hoped in the summertime.
A week after alighting, we were taking down the tent. An hour later, we were once again airborne, and on our journey home.
We left an area noted for being untouched and famed for the diversity of its wildlife. In the small plane, we passed over miles of tumbling waterfalls, virgin rivers and traversed a lake even larger than Tahoe. We flew past peaks, through narrow mountain passes and over glaciers.
George was right. Outsiders like me think of Alaska as a playground, something to protect. But I’m not willing to take a nuclear waste dump at Yucca Mountain in trade.
Discussion: 1 comment so far…
Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.
Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.
No trusted comments have been posted.
Post a comment
Most Popular
- Viewed
- Discussed
- E-mailed
- ‘Michael Jackson One’ is Cirque du Soleil’s best — and includes snow at Mandalay Bay
- It’s back! New Wet ‘n’ Wild wins over frolickers thirsty for Vegas water park
- Firefly set to reopen on Paradise after salmonella outbreak
- Superstar DJ Memorial Day Weekend kicks off battle of Las Vegas nightclubs
- Sex education bill loses its momentum, dies in Nevada Senate









This lovely pastoral "back to nature" account just goes to show you how out of whack many Nevadans' priorities are: The author and his old friends, vacationing amidst the natural beauty of Alaska, talk of all the important issues of our time while sitting around a lovely campfire, and the one subject that seems to produce an awkward silence is...
Yucca Mountain???
Come on, give me a break.
The author, like so many Nevadans, is like a passenger on the Titanic who complains that the deck chairs are uncomfortable as the vessel slowly sinks into the watery deep.
Even worse, he sets up a false analogy between Alaska being "co-opted" by environmentalists for a "Nature Playground" and Yucca Mountain being similarly co-opted for a nuclear waste repository.
In the first place, even the author's intended contrast isn't accurate: He would have us think that the withdrawal of land in Alaska for "natural enjoyment" is dramatically different than withdrawal of land in Nevada for a "dangerous" repository. The former, the author implies, is clearly a worthy pursuit, while the latter is clearly not.
But all of that is based in the premise that Yucca Mountain will indeed be dangerous, which scientific study after scientific study has proven is not the case. In fact, Alaska is probably subject to vastly greater environmental risks merely from the presence of the oil industry there, as witnessed the Exxon Valdez accident.
Yucca, by contrast, is over 90 miles away from Vegas (not "close to Vegas," as the author suggests), and the greatest calculated dose risk at the boundary of the site, at its peak, is comparable to an x-ray exam. And by the way, that peak happens thousands of years from now.
Get some perspective, Dude. Your fear of Yucca Mountain was given to you by Harry Reid and the rest of the Nevada political establishment. It is a phantom and has nothing in common with the very real and daily environmental risks experienced by Alaskans (not to mention personal risks that literally come with the territory).
You made yourself look like a schmuck by trying to argue with your friends that Nevadans are subject to any risk comparable to Alaskans simply by the presence of a nuclear repository at Yucca Mountain.
That, my friend, was the reason for the awkward silence: Your friends were embarrassed for you.