Las Vegas Sun

June 4, 2012

Currently: 98° | Complete forecast | Log in

LETTER TO THE EDITOR:

Americans have lost compassion for downtrodden

Sunday, Sept. 5, 2010 | 2:03 a.m.

Regarding the first-person article Sunday, “I Am Frightened,” by Rodger Jacobs, who was on the brink of becoming homeless:

What frightens me is not the article itself (though to be sure, it is a nightmare scenario) but the comments on the website at the end of the article.

This is depressing. Some of these comments are sickening.

What happened to America, land of boundless compassion, wisdom, feelings for the plight of one’s fellow man?

I cannot even begin to fathom whatever tortuous path has led us to arrive at these utterly savage comments, where the desperate times on which a man has fallen aren’t even acknowledged as fact, much less treated with any kind of sympathy.

How have we reached the point where it is automatically the victim’s fault? Jacobs has spent his life as a hardworking, productive member of society. I assume he’s paid his taxes regularly, and now he’s on the receiving end of the same system that he spent his adult life paying into.

That’s how it works. You support today’s elderly and infirm so that tomorrow a younger generation will support you. As Baby Boomers, your parents gave you absolutely everything, and asked only that you “pay it forward.”

Instead, the past three decades have been spent attempting to dismantle the social safety net that has allowed Americans to live without fear of poverty.

This is America. We take care of one another. We respect one another’s right to worship in a manner of their choosing.

We believe that gainful employment is to be encouraged, but when honest attempts at seeking such employment fail, we will help you. Because we are America, and we care about one another.

What the hell is happening in this country?

Discussion: 8 comments so far…

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

  1. Look at the depression. "They Shoot Horses Don't They?"

    In hard times schadenfreude takes hold among the right wing stink tank and tea party types.

    The guy featured in the article may have made some bad decisions, but so did Rush Limbaugh, Glen Buck, Betty Ford and W Bush.

    The 75% of Nevadans who are upside down in their homes might have made different decisions in hindsight as well.

    Do the people who worked on the Dam Hoover Bypass Bridge have jobs? So "government can help in job creation" is just another load of crap from the hate talk radio crowd.

  2. "I, Me, Mine".

    FOX.
    BECK.
    HANNITY.
    RUSH.
    PALIN.
    ET.AL
    Each and every day, they tell the masses how GREAT it is to HATE.
    It's a massive right-wing, Neo-Con, NutJob indoctrination into the brave new world of SELFISHNESS.
    What these talking-heads are paid handsomely to do is inspire HATRED for your fellow man.
    It's not only "OKAY", it's your DUTY! Don't YOU want to be a "Great American"???
    Look what they WANT from you! The LAST NICKEL from your pants pocket! Are you going to LET THEM TAKE IT?
    HELL NO!!!
    Well then, DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT!
    Hate your fellow man!
    Hate your neighbor!
    Hate your co-worker who doesn't hate!
    Hate your heads off!
    The proliferation of "I'm a right-wing Hater" in the United States Of America, driven by the UBER RICH and their Neo-Nut Media Machine, is fast becoming the bane of our existence.
    95% of the recruits to the Right-Wing Hater's Club join "the Program" in diametric opposition to their own best interests.
    But then, THAT'S THE WHOLE IDEA!!!

  3. The letter writer took away a much more negative feeling from the posts at the end of Rodger Jacobs' article than I did.
    I saw the vast majority of comments as somewhat sympathetic but at the same time offering constructive criticism.
    In my opinion both the Las Vegas Sun and Rodger Jacobs can take immense pride in the article. This and future articles by the Sun about local poverty might reap an award of some sort.
    As far as Rodger is concerned, I expect that this article is the crowning achievement of his writing career, and as he looks back on it over the years, he will have nothing but pride in it.
    The article is of excellent quality and the response was immense, the most comments I have ever seen posted in the Sun. Assuming Rodger's motive was to bring light to the human face of poverty, he has succeeded totally, even though by putting out his personal situation for all to read, he demonstrated that sometimes small poor personal choices (like resorting to a payday loan, or continuing to smoke) can impact one's financial situation in a bad recession.
    This was the most interesting article I have ever read in the Las Vegas Sun.

  4. If Social Security and Medicare were to be phased out would that portion of tax no longer come out of my check. I mean there's a lot of people that believe that but has anyone actually said that it would or would the tax continue by form of re appropriations or will it go into an account that someone on wall street can invest for me and they get there commission off of there advise or will they impose some sort of account maintenance fee for managing the account.
    The reason I ask this is that these wall street investors tell people all the time that you should invest for long term while they invest for the moment with your money that's why they call that money in your bank account as being on the sideline. I can't help but think that that agenda is big business oriented for them and not you they cant stand the fact that you control your money and they can't force you into the game.
    What do I mean when I say you control your own money you asked? Well lets look at long term investment into your fellow citizen for example the long term return is the fact that you have a safety net we pay for our elders and when we become the elders then we can be assisted as well keeping in mind that social security was not to be a retirement but only a supplement to your retirement now not all people draw off of there Social Security most will pass away before they are able to draw then there are those that will draw for only a short time while in the 90's the average number of checks received before the recipient died was 13 the dreaded unlucky number, Also there are those that live a long time and may draw for 6 or 8 to 10 year or more and that's why it is needed because you have lived so long you have now out lived any savings you may have acquired.
    The bottom line is this that investment by way of Social Security is the lest Risky with the best return.
    And our founding fathers made our constitution amendable the greatest thing they did Imagine Amendable by our Representatives. And that is why I say you control your money.

  5. Nothing in the Constitution provides for veterans benefits. They are just as socialistic as Social Security, Medicare and unemployment insurance, if not more so. That is why Senator Alan Simpson is saying the "Veterans are hurting America" by their insatiable demands.

    Funds are taken from employees and employers for Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment INSURANCE. Insurance programs.

    SO to be ideologically consistent, people like "nez.." should look at the Military as the largest group of socialists in American Society.

    Just take a look at all the new GOVERNMENT housing out at places like Nellis. Like there is not enough vacant housing in Las Vegas for the military people? In fact military people would be safer out in the community than concentrated on a base. Plus it would help the local real estate market.

    Then look at the whole military contractor issue. How many billions of "income redistribution" are involved there?

    Let us fight socialism by cuts in the US Military.

    If the guy feature in the story was a Military Person (many Military families on food stamps) or if he was a VET, the venom and vitriol my be contained.

  6. bg
    That is precisely my point why? would I or you want to move from a system that gives great returns for one that is going to ruled by someone else and we would be nickeled and dimed to the point where there would be no return or a safety net.

  7. Americanpatriot

    Excellent post I remember seeing a poll that took place about a year ago and the jest of it was that more than 50% of the population does not have a designated religious group such as catholic or baptist etc. and I found that I was in that group because I got tired of going to church to worship and all I would hear from the pulpit was Rush Limbaugh or the same and then they would pass the plate for the collection, I believe that is the reason people don't go as much because the christian coalition and the republicans are trying to push there agenda by way of the church. The comparison that you used about my brothers keeper that was a correct comparison.

  8. What Happened?

    America voted in a man who hates 50 per cent of America - who calls them names. America voted into power a man who thinks that 10 per cent unemployment is just fine; it will be here for a long time so live with it. Obama is a man who thinks we should pay millions for the secret service for his golf trips, dinner dates, and wife's lavish travels to Europe. America voted in a mean spirited President, who slams half of America every time he can. He refuses to take responsibility; he hates so many things. His wife hated America until her husband was elected President.

    When you have such a horrible role model as President of the United States, it only follows that some will try to be just like him and slam others. President Obama has slammed the military; the military families; and so many others.

    I disliked the comments yesterday too - but it is time to realize that the President is totally and completely at fault for his total lack of being a role model. \ When the news covers such people every day - it only follows that some readers try their hand at Obama-speak. Its sad; its horrible; and its unfortunate.

    Where have our statesmen gone in office? we are stuck with a handful of fools in Washington DC for our children to look up to....
    How do you explain to your kids to be nice when Obama is not. And how do you tell your child its ok to want to be president; but place try to be nicer and kinder than the one you see on TV. Its a wierd world due to the fact that he slams so many people each day instead of want to build bridges like those who were there before him.

Post a comment

Commenting requires registration.

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy.

If you would like to submit your comment as a letter to the editor, you may submit it here.