Countrywide Financial, KB Home accused of inflating home prices

Friday, May 8, 2009 | 2:21 p.m.

Countrywide to lower interest rates in settlement (3-2-2009)

Real Estate in Crisis

Countrywide lawsuit

Countrywide Financial is accused in a new lawsuit of teaming up with KB Home to inflate prices on new homes in Arizona and Nevada -- allegedly hurting consumers by placing them in deals with negative equity without their consent.

Attorneys representing a group of homeowners said Thursday they filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Arizona seeking class-action status against KB Home, Countrywide Financial and LandSafe Appraisal Services, claiming the three conspired to illegally rig home appraisals in KB developments in an effort to boost home values and sales prices.

The suit claims KB and the other defendants inflated home prices by as much as $280 million in Arizona and Nevada alone during a three-year period beginning in 2005.

""It is particularly unfortunate in these challenging times that predatory attorneys file baseless lawsuits. We look forward to proving the lawsuit is without merit," responded Craig LeMessurier, KB Home's regional director of public relations. Officials at Bank of America could not immediately be reached for comment on the allegations involving Countrywide, which was purchased by B of A and is now called Bank of America Home Loans.

Rob Carey, the attorney representing the plaintiffs who allege racketeering by the defendants, said KB routed purchasers to Countrywide for loan services.

"Countrywide and KB were in cahoots, intent on sticking the homeowner with an inflated home appraisal to justify the purchase price," Carey said.

Countrywide allegedly funneled all its KB customers' home appraisals to one person at LandSafe, an appraisal subsidiary of Countrywide who, in turn, would deliver an appraisal value at whatever KB and Countrywide ordered.

In two KB Home developments cited in the complaint, sampled appraisals were inflated by $82,169 per property on average, the suit charges.

"Even if we used a more conservative $20,000 per property, this alleged scheme would add ($280 million) in ill-gotten profits in KB's pockets," Carey said. "Those profits come at the expense of the homeowner, who moves into a house already upside-down, and the secondary market, buying tainted investments."

The complaint sites instances of appraisals that used pending sales within the same development as comparable properties substantiating appraisal values.

This is just the latest headache for Bank of America since it bought Countrywide, which played a big role in the subprime mortgage meltdown and in March settled a predatory lending complaint filed by the Nevada Attorney General's office.

In other recent cases:

--American International Group Inc. sued Countrywide in March, alleging Countrywide misrepresented the health of loans that the company insured, resulting in massive losses to AIG.

--A shareholders' lawsuit is progressing against Countrywide's former chairman and chief executive, Angelo Mozilo. Shareholders are complaining that he improperly profited by selling stock. The lawsuit explains how Countrywide shifted away from traditional fixed-rate mortgages toward riskier loans, such as subprime and adjustable rate mortgages. It claims the change created more risk for shareholders, who lost money when the company's stock price dropped in 2007.

--The Florida Attorney General's office continues to pursue a deceptive trade practices case against Mozillo.

This story has been corrected. The suit claims KB and the other defendants inflated home prices by as much as $280 million.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Discussion: 7 comments so far…

By vmanstuff

5/8/09 at 3:17 p.m.

Suggest removal

What are the two KB home developments cited in the complaint?
By AngryReader

5/8/09 at 4:19 p.m.

Suggest removal

This class action should be expanded to anyone who bought a home in these areas during the period of this collusion to artifically inflate prices. If the allegations are true, the actions would have impact on any homebuyer in the area.

Rob Carey needs to get this thing expanded to cover all the injured, not just KB home buyers.
By mcmc_john

5/8/09 at 4:48 p.m.

Suggest removal

I hate to be the one who said I told ya so... hmmmm builders and mortgage companies aligned to deceive the public for ungodly profits or was that ill-gotten profits?
By cnev

5/8/09 at 4:48 p.m.

Suggest removal

Congratulations, Las Vegas Sun!
Keep digging-KB probably isn't the only builder who colluded to inflate prices with appraisers and mortgage companies.
It's too bad the state of Nevada doesn't have a mechanism to investigate this type of corruption-and if they do-please educate us.
By neiman1

5/8/09 at 5:53 p.m.

Suggest removal

Now we are getting to the real meat on the bone. Once qualifying for a loan didn't matter, it was all in. Keep each round of homes costing more, and apprasing for more. Higher profit let the home builder "buy down" the initial interest rate, making the payment lower and lower buy using false profits. The loan fees and kick backs went up and it was like ACORN signing up voters. Put each person in a bigger and bigger home with less and less value until the sky fell in.
By its2hot

5/9/09 at 4:16 p.m.

Suggest removal

It would seem that the consumers are finally wising up and taking on the very ones who screwed America. Another suit filed, lol.

Shareholders File Class Action Suit Against eAppraiserIT / WaMU For "Requesting" Artificially Inflated Appraisals

The class claims WaMu was eAppraiseIT's largest customer. Plaintiffs claim that Santa Ana-based

"eAppriaseIT, at Washington Mutual's urging, provided materially false and inflated appraisals for properties where Washington Mutual sought to originate a mortgage. This enabled Washington Mutual to engage in real estate mortgage transactions that would otherwise have been untenable had the property at issue been correctly appraised".

They alledge "Senior executives at First American were aware of and willing to accommodate the request to falsify appraisals. Washington Mutual's competitive place in the market and profit were driven in large part by the number of mortgages it issued based upon artificially inflated appraisals issued by eAppriaseIT."
By HookorCrook

8/4/09 at 9:21 p.m.

Suggest removal

Countrywide Class Action Lawsuit Nevada http://www.scribd.com/doc/17911095/Count...