Foreclosures forcing debt on HOAs

Friday, Oct. 31, 2008 | midnight

Real Estate in Crisis

Nevada homeowners associations may square off against banks in the 2009 Legislature over fines and assessments that are piling up against foreclosed homes — and over the failure of homeowners and mortgage holders to maintain some of the vacant homes.

HOAs are frustrated because some of the foreclosed homes become eyesores with overgrown vegetation and have green, foul-smelling pools. They're upset because homeowners frequently fail to pay HOA assessments prior to abandoning the properties. And homeowners and mortgage holders often fail to pay assessments and fines during the foreclosure process that can drag on for nine months or longer.

Bankers, too, are frustrated. They're tired of being blamed for problems caused by homeowners who default on their loans and then abandon properties, leaving no one to take care of them or pay HOA assessments.

Bill Uffelman, chief executive officer of the Nevada Bankers Association, said that HOAs tend to forget that banks have no way of knowing when homeowners stop paying HOA assessments. It is not until after 90 days of nonpayment on the mortgage that banks have any right to file a notice of default. Nine months typically elapse from the day that the homeowner stops paying until the day that the bank owns the home again.

"During that time banks have no rights relative to the property," Uffelman said. "Nobody can even enter onto the property. Everyone says, "banks should do this or banks should do that,' but that's not what the law is."

Ken Hill, president of the Red Rock Country Club Homeowners Association, sees it differently. His Summerlin HOA, like others, must absorb more bad debt than it would like to because the law requires banks or lenders to pay no more than six months of retroactive assessment fees. And there is no law allowing retroactive fines for not maintaining landscaping or pools.

The HOA will have to raise its 2009 monthly assessment largely because of bad debts, Hill said. He declined to say how much the assessment would increase.

"Each homeowner is paying for somebody else's bad debt," Hill said.

For health reasons, the Red Rock Country Club HOA has paid to have pools maintained. The HOA then not only bills the property owner for the cost of maintenance, but also levies a fine for the owner's failure to drain the pool.

Fees and fines continue to pile up, but in many cases the HOA has no hope of collecting what it's owed.

"What I want to see is that if a bank forecloses and becomes the owner, that they are required to take care of any outstanding debt (or liens) on the house. That is what is required for any other property owner. It should be the same for banks," Hill said.

State Sen. Bob Beers, R-Summerlin said lenders should have to pay more than six months of assessments.

"An owner is an owner is an owner," he said. "It doesn't matter to me if the bank or lender is the owner, you have an obligation to participate in fees for HOAs as you contracted to do."

Beers said that banks should add the retroactive assessment fees liens from HOAs on the home into part of the price for new buyers.

State Sen. Mike Schneider, D-Spring Valley, has introduced a bill that would require lenders of foreclosed homes to maintain property including landscaping and pools, which would require the water and power to be kept on.

"Banks a lot of the time are their own worst enemies," he said. "There are a lot of deep discounts on foreclosed homes because the landscaping is shot and there is no appeal to people to buy the homes, but banks are discounting $300,000 homes to $150,000 when they don't need to if they would maintain the property. "

Schneider said he's also pushing the bill because of health hazards that come from non-maintained pools and because values of homes in the community go down because of neglect.

"It affects our tax base," he said. "Property taxes go down and we lose funding for schools."

Hill doubts legislators will seriously crack down on banks, considering many are struggling with bad real estate loans, some have failed and some are being bailed out by the federal government. He also fears that if banks must pay more past-due assessments, the foreclosure process will drag on even longer.

"I prefer that we try to compromise with banks," Hill said. "Instead of requiring them to pay 18 to 24 months in back assessments, have them pay for at least a year."

Jenny Davis can be reached at 990-8921 or jenny.davis@hbcpub.com.

Discussion: 6 comments so far…

By MikeRR

10/31/08 at 4:58 a.m.

Suggest removal

Tell ya what KEN HILL...let the FBI come in and go through your books, and supervise your next election...then we will take you and your HOA seriously!
I thought HOAs kept up property values...just another lie exposing what a scam HOAs really are
By azsk8fan

10/31/08 at 5:53 a.m.

Suggest removal

HOA's do keep up the property values but when the community is riddled with foreclosures and the fees aren't being paid then what - it takes money to keep the community as a whole looking good but HOA funds are depleting because so many are not paying their dues.
By stevem

10/31/08 at 6:11 a.m.

Suggest removal

hoa's have been screwing over people for years. if i go out of town for a week i come home to a letter saying i have a fine for weeds...

...even though i have nothing but rocks in the front of my house.
By HOAGOV

10/31/08 at 8:29 a.m.

Suggest removal

The HOA president believes that ALL liens are handled by forceclosure, and thinks the banks should be made to pay for all liens. Not so! Mortgages are in first position and all other liens are extinguished, unless, of course, the HOA buys the property at foreclosure to protect its secondary liens. Yes, the HOA must first pay off the mortgage.

The president also laments about the nonpayment of fines, as if the fine was important to the operation and survival of the HOA. No, they are not! Fines are punitive in nature, serving as a detriment to the individual, and to others, to pay their bills. They are personal in nature.
By KDR81

10/31/08 at 8:45 a.m.

Suggest removal

HOA's are mini privatized governments, if you will. People hate them because they are direct and the "tax" you pay is very visible.

On the other hand the County Commissioners, City government, and state government are infinitely more powerful...but not as many people hate them. In fact, there is a whole party dedicated to telling us what a wonderful job they do.

But guess what? There transactions are not transparent and neither is the way they tax you.

If an HOA, an organization you voluntarily entered, is bad, what does that make real governments that you had no choice but to pay or go to jail?
By MikeRR

10/31/08 at 4:22 p.m.

Suggest removal

Who enters an HOA voluntarily? Nobody! We just want to buy a house...it comes with the darn HOA. The disclosure of what we are getting into is hidden in hundreds of pages of garbage.
As far as HOAs keeping up the value...that is a lie. A study published by Harvard University said that HOAs do NOT add value to our homes!!!
They are a scam that benefit the developer and the municipality. They are pathological because they then attract losers into feeling as if they have some power and will do anything to perpetrate the things.

« Previous Ten Next Ten »

Live chat: Tuesday, noon PST; Chat with Krista Creelman; Problem Gambling Center executive director Krista Creelman will answer questions about gambling addiction from Las Vegas Sun readers from noon to 1 p.m. Tuesday, Nov. ... Submit question