LOOKING IN ON: CARSON CITY:
Slot company loses case to worker who blew whistle
In separate suit, court says Sparks casino’s food comps can’t be taxed
Sun, Mar 30, 2008 (2 a.m.)
Carson City The Nevada Supreme Court has given wider protection to whistleblowers who report their employers’ illegal activities.
The court has ruled there must be a district court trial in Reno to allow James McAndrews to prove he was fired after he claimed that International Game Technology fraudulently concealed sales and use tax money owed to the state.
McAndrews sued in 2003, claiming that the giant slot machine company and its subsidiaries owed up to $50 million in back taxes to the state. Under the law, he would have been entitled to a percentage of that figure if he proved his case.
But the Nevada Supreme Court rejected McAndrews’ suit in 2006. Shortly after that, McAndrews was fired.
He then filed another suit claiming the company had improperly fired him. He sought back wages, special damages, costs and attorney fees. The company argued the law allows employees to collect damages only if they are pressured into performing illegal acts and report the activities to authorities.
District Judge Connie Steinheimer of Reno ruled against the company, which appealed to state Supreme Court.
In a unanimous decision written by Justice James Hardesty, the state high court also ruled against the slot machine company. The company’s interpretation, Hardesty said, would void the Legislature’s policy “to protect employees who have acted lawfully” under the Nevada False Claims Act’s anti-retaliation section.
•••
In a victory for casinos, the Nevada Supreme Court has ruled that the state’s sales and use tax cannot be imposed on complimentary meals for guests and employees.
In a 6-1 decision, the court said no taxable event occurs when a casino buys tax-exempt food and then gives it away to patrons or workers.
As a result, the Sparks Nugget is entitled to a $501,369 refund on taxes paid to the state from April 1, 1999, to Feb. 28, 2002, the court said.
The ruling overturns the decision of District Judge Brent Adams, who had sided with the taxation department in ruling the company owed the taxes.
Although the Nugget taxes meals purchased by patrons, it does not tax complimentary meals to customers and employees. The state, however, thought the complimentary meals were taxable.
The court, though, agreed with the Nugget’s position that giving away tax-exempt food does not constitute a taxable event.
Justice Michael Douglas dissented, noting that a prior court decision held that “tax exemptions are strictly construed in favor of finding taxability and that any reasonable doubt about whether an exemption applies must be construed against the taxpayer.”
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Editors’ Picks
- Tip-sharing cloud forming over Encore, Wynn critics say
- Allen discusses marital problems in mailer
- Jenna Jameson pregnant?
- Home sales up for 7th month; prices fall
- Unlicensed board clears hurdle to control Tropicana
- Thunderstorms bring street flooding to Las Vegas area
- In search of goatee symmetry
- Despite abuse reports, state sent accused employers more J-1 docs
- Man, 24, dies in single-car crash
- Larger stadiums, better teams?
Blogs
Politics: The Early Line
Nevada political roundup: Clinton, McCain visits put Vegas in spotlight
Elsewhere
Filming starts on ‘Saint John of Las Vegas’
Politics: Ralston's Flash
Gibbons to Ethics Commission: Throw out complaint (1 Comment)
Culture Blog
Criss Angel 'loyals' get first glimpse of theater
Sports: UNLV
UNLV guard Wink Adams chats with fans Friday
Vegas News
Millionaire chancellor packs a lunch for regents meeting
Sports: UNLV
Thursday practice notes: Patterson busts out the gloves (2 Comments)
Politics: The Early Line
Nevada political roundup: Parties spar over gas prices (2 Comments)
Calendar
Joel McHale at Mandalay Bay Theatre
E!'s funnyman performs stand up at Mandalay Bay (9 p.m. to 11:59 p.m. Mandalay Bay)
- Maze featuring Frankie Beverly (9 p.m.)
- Travis Tritt (8 p.m.)
- Amplify's Best of Show finale featuring I Hate Kate at Jillian's (6:30 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.)
- Michael Grimm (6 p.m. to 9 p.m.)
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.

Post a comment
Commenting requires registration.
Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Full comments policy.