Las Vegas Sun

August 8, 2008

State Medical Board left out of loop

Investigations chief, slowed by others’ moves, vows to make up for lost time

By Marshall Allen

Fri, Mar 14, 2008 (2 a.m.)

In Today's Sun

Sun Topics

Face to Face video

Sun Archives

Beyond the Sun

Two weeks ago Doug Cooper read about the massive hepatitis C scare triggered at a Las Vegas clinic where nurses were engaging in dangerous injection practices, apparently at the direction of their boss, a doctor.

Cooper was flabbergasted, but not for reasons you might expect.

Cooper is chief of investigations for the Nevada State Medical Board, which issues licenses for doctors and polices their treatment of patients. He knew nothing about the multiagency investigation that had gone on for more than a month before the Feb. 27 announcement that 40,000 people should get tested for hepatitis B, hepatitis C and HIV.

Since then, Cooper’s life has grown only more complicated.

“Everyone is going on innuendo and rumor and it’s hard to keep focused and keep people focused on what we have to do,” Cooper said. “There is a rush to judgment.”

Indeed, many Nevadans have insisted on suspension of the medical licenses of Dr. Dipak Desai, one of the state’s most prominent physicians, and 13 other doctors. All worked at the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada, an outpatient surgery center, and the Gastroenterology Center of Nevada, its related medical practice.

Desai voluntarily agreed to stop practicing medicine while the investigation continues. But the gentlemen’s agreement will not show up on his permanent record. And the other owners of the Endoscopy Center — Dr. Eladio Carrera, Dr. Vishvinder Sharma and Dr. Clifford Carrol — are still practicing.

Dr. Ronald Kline, secretary of the Nevada State Medical Association, which represents physicians, said Thursday that the state’s good doctors have no desire to protect the bad ones. He said he can’t speak for the medical board, but thinks Desai’s license should be suspended.

“Given the charges that were there, it certainly makes sense that (Desai) should not be practicing medicine until the charges are cleared,” Kline said.

Cooper said the medical board is considering suspending the doctors’ licenses. But the politics and reality of such an action are complicated.

First, there are the lawyers. The doctors are wealthy enough — Desai recently started a bank, for instance — to hire teams of attorneys.

Cooper said he must ensure the doctors have their due process so the medical board doesn’t get sued for violating their civil rights.

Also, the medical community is close-knit, so some members of the medical board have close connections to Desai, who ran the largest gastroenterology practice in the state.

Board member Dr. Stephen McBride, the managing partner in General Surgery Associates, shares a medical building with Desai at 700 Shadow Lane. Staff members there would not say whether the two referred patients to each other.

Dr. Javaid Anwar, president of the medical board, has done consulting for Desai through Quality Care Consultants, which he co-owns with Dr. Ikram Khan, Gov. Jim Gibbons’ special adviser on health care. Anwar could not be reached for comment.

Khan said he does not expect connections to Desai and his partners to be a problem in the medical board’s investigation or possible disciplinary action because the Nevada attorney general’s office will force recusal by anyone with conflicts of interest.

Cooper said he has taken steps to protect the investigation from undue influence by board members. He said the investigation is being supervised by three members of the board — two physicians from Northern Nevada who don’t know Desai and a layperson.

Even though two weeks have passed since the revelations, Cooper remains steamed that he was never notified about the investigation by the Southern Nevada Health District, the state Licensure and Certification Bureau and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Medical board investigators sprang into action when they finally heard the news. Within 18 business hours of learning of the situation, medical board investigators were at the door of the Endoscopy Center with a subpoena, ready to grab the records they needed.

But it was locked. Las Vegas had already shut the place down.

A week later, other law enforcement agencies — the FBI, the Nevada attorney general’s office and Metro Police among them — swept into the clinics with a search warrant and cleaned house, seizing computer hardware and patient files.

If the medical board had known before the public announcement, investigators “would have been so much farther ahead of the game,” Cooper said. The board could have grabbed necessary evidence and developed confidential sources among clinic employees, he said.

Lisa Jones, chief of the Licensure and Certification Bureau, said she thought the medical board had been notified weeks before the announcement. But messages got crossed and fell through the cracks in the chaos, she said.

“My error,” Jones said.

Cooper said the medical board will do a complete investigation, even if it does take more time.

“We will solve this mystery and present to the board a cohesive package of what happened and who did what,” he said.

Discussion: 9 comments so far…

  1. By localcitizen
    3/14/08 at 6:33 a.m.
    Suggest removal

    Am I reading this correctly? Some of the members of the Board have close connections to Desai? So what? I thought the Board's mission was to protect the public, not the doctors. Those board members with any conflicts should ethically recuse themselves from the investigation. As a patient, I am outraged that the Board would close ranks and protect its own. Take emergency action now to protect the public and sort out the legalities later. I can't believe the other people are practicing and that nothing is being done to their licenses. I can't imagine that any court would say the doctors were denied due process, given what the CDC and Health District have uncovered in their investigations.

  2. By Judy
    3/14/08 at 8:13 a.m.
    Suggest removal

    Ah, so now we hear of the tie to Gob'ner Gibbons. His appointed (annointed) special adviser on health care is partners with Desai.No wonder we did not need more oversight, more inspectors. This clown in the governors mansion is all about the buck.

    Nevadans deserve better!

  3. By Beezie
    3/14/08 at 8:31 a.m.
    Suggest removal

    At this point, I'm not convinced the board would have acted with impartiality due the gross conflict of interest even if they had been in the loop. Cooper's own statements show how politically incestuous the board is. With regard to the other physicians still practicing, perhaps suspension of all licenses would be in the public interest pending the outcome of all investigations. But why would we expect common sense to prevail?

  4. By nvkorruption
    3/14/08 at 11:17 a.m.
    Suggest removal

    'If the medical board had known before the public announcement, investigators “would have been so much farther ahead of the game,” Cooper said. The board could have grabbed necessary evidence and developed confidential sources among clinic employees, he said.'

    No time to bury the evidence? Sweet!!!!

  5. By Beezie
    3/14/08 at 12:11 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    Amen to Judy and nvkorruption !!!
    I noticed how Cooper used the word 'grabbed'. Not gathered or collected. This freakin' story keeps getting better and better. This state puts Louisiana politics to shame and who in their right mind could make this crap up! Perhaps someone could just tie all the recent scandals together for us into a neat little package ala 6 degrees of Kevin Bacon(aka Small World Theory). Starts out: Desai/Gibbons/state board/Dr.Bass/stateboard/Desai/UMC/Lacey/Atkinson-Gates... ad nauseum. It wouldn't take someone with a beautiful mind to connect the yarns to the pushpins. ;)

  6. By mgkrebsii
    3/14/08 at 2:08 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    This article clearly shows that investigations and the board need to be separate entities. Investigations cannot and should not work for the board. It should report its findings to the board.

  7. By CynicalObserver
    3/14/08 at 8:47 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    Doug Cooper obviously has never seen the movie Serpico, or any other movie about the real world problem of leaks of information coming out of law enforcement agencies into the ears of "bad guys". Typically the FBI doesn't trust local cops and vice versa.

    So why in the world would any public health law enforcement agency trust anyone at the Board of Medical Examiners or the State Health Department when both of those agencies have been heavy infiltrated by "foxes in the hen house".

    The Board of Medical Examiners will never get any respect as long as its members are political appointees.

  8. By MM745
    3/14/08 at 9:31 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    Ugh, when is Lisa Jones going to be fired?! Incompetent twit.

  9. By DoubleA
    3/17/08 at 6:52 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    "Cooper said the medical board is considering suspending the doctors’ licenses. But the politics and reality of such an action are complicated." Since when do "politics" out-weigh patient safety and proper medical procedures. Sadly it took the City of Las Vegas to close the clinic. Where was the State Medical Board? Apparently they were busy being "flabbergasted" by the investigation that was underway. It appears that by the time they actually get around to doing anything, there won't really be anything left to do.

Post a comment

Commenting requires registration.

Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Full comments policy.

Username:
Password: (Forgotten your password?)

OR Create an account (It's free)

Calendar

Joel McHale at Mandalay Bay Theatre

Joel McHale at Mandalay Bay Theatre

E!'s funnyman performs stand up at Mandalay Bay (9 p.m. to 11:59 p.m. Mandalay Bay)