Print
E-mail
Share
iPod
del.icio.us
digg
Newsvine
FacebookAssembly-line colonoscopies at clinic described
Unorthodox scheduling, billing practices saved money, witnesses say
Leila Navidi
Duke Breuer, a former patient of the Endoscopy Center of Souther Nevada, is awaiting blood test results to see whether he contracted an infectious disease.
Sun, Mar 9, 2008 (3 a.m.)
Endoscopy Patient Reacts
Beyond the Sun
If you want to get a sense of the rushed medical procedures that patients encountered inside the clinic that triggered the unprecedented hepatitis scare, consider Duke Breuer’s experience.
After undergoing a colonoscopy at the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada, Breuer asked a nurse what he should do about the bandage on his right forearm.
“Take it off when you get home,” the nurse said.
Later, when the 78-year-old Breuer pulled up the tape, he started gushing blood. The IV needle had been left in his arm and he had accidentally yanked it out.
Blood spurted with each beat of his heart — “Poom! Poom! Poom!” is how Breuer describes it. The darkest blood he’d ever seen, covering his pants and ruining his beloved Chinese silk rug.
So Breuer was none too happy when he returned to the facility a few days later for a second procedure.
“I ought to sue you for ruining my rug,” he told a nurse.
Her response stunned him.
“You ought to sue us for a lot of other things that go on here,” Breuer says the nurse replied. “You don’t know what goes on here. I hate my boss.”
He dismissed her as a disgruntled employee.
Then, 10 days ago, the Southern Nevada Health District announced that 40,000 people might have been infected with hepatitis B, hepatitis C or HIV because of dangerous injection practices at the downtown endoscopy center.
Dr. Dipak Desai, majority owner of the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada, leaves Las Vegas City Hall on March 3. Desai has surrendered his medical license pending the outcome of a state investigation.
Never, it seems, has the community been so collectively outraged as now, with the news that patients were put at risk of being infected with fatal diseases because of a doctor’s drumbeat to save money.
According to investigators, the nurses claimed that Dr. Dipak Desai, one of the state’s most powerful physicians and owner of the clinic, had ordered the dangerous practices. When patients needed more anesthetic, the nurses were using the same syringe to dip back into the vial. That tainted the medicine. Then, even though the vials were intended for single use, the nurses would reuse them on other patients. That passed along infection. Little money would be saved by reusing syringes, but reusing the medicine could save $5 to $10 per procedure, experts estimated.
Six people contracted acute hepatitis C because of the dangerous injection practices, health officials said, and now thousands more await the results of blood tests.
The clinic has been closed by the city.
Why did Desai apparently ignore established, fundamental medical safety?
Medicine is business. And in an era of rising health care costs and dropping insurance reimbursement rates, physicians balance the pursuit of profit with patient care. But those who know Desai and worked with him say his downfall was greed. Desai proudly proclaimed that he ran the most cost-effective clinic in the entire country.
A nurse who worked for Desai said his business plan called for extreme cost-cutting measures. A doctor who has worked with Desai said he was proud of churning through procedures at an impossibly fast pace. He said he witnessed Desai perform in a few minutes a colonoscopy that should have taken 15 minutes. And then brag about it.
“He’d say, ‘I’m the fastest endoscopist, the best endoscopist, in town,’ ” recalled the doctor, who like others asked for anonymity for fear of reprisals. “That was his pride and joy.”
In crude gastroenterology parlance, Desai would be known as a “jammer.”
Desai’s public relations consultant said the doctor would not consent to an interview for this story.
By many measures Desai is a success. He attended medical school in India and completed his residency and an internship in New York before he and his wife, Dr. Kusum Desai, a pulmonary specialist, were licensed to practice medicine in Nevada in 1980.
Desai has been chief of gastroenterology at University Medical Center and Valley Hospital & Medical Center, and a professor at the University of Nevada School of Medicine. The couple owns a $3.4 million, 8,700-square-foot home in Summerlin.
A friend credits him for helping to found the Hindu Temple of Nevada and donating $250,000 to it.
But the friend asked not to be identified because of what else he had to say about the doctor: that Desai is aggressive, intense and preoccupied with business.
“If he cannot achieve something with you he will forget you in a minute,” the friend said.
The Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada opened in March 2004 in a medical building at 700 Shadow Lane, between two of the city’s largest hospitals — and across the street from the offices of the Southern Nevada Health District, which launched its surprise inspections of the facility in January.
The business complements Desai’s Gastroenterology Center of Nevada, which has six valley locations.
Although other doctors worked at the high-volume facility, it was Desai’s domain.
Appointments were frequently double-booked, leading to two-hour waits in a standing-room-only waiting room, said a nurse who worked there in 2007.
In assembly-line fashion, patients were hurried among nurses who would admit them, start an IV in their arm, take them to the room for the procedure, and then walk them to a recovery area before sending them out the door.
“He would always say, ‘Time is money,’ ” the nurse said of Desai. “The faster we would go, the happier he was.”
The flow of patients sounds impossibly fast, said Phyllis McGregor, a nurse who for 20 years directed the gastroenterology department at Centinela Hospital Medical Center in Inglewood, Calif.
She ran three rooms where a total of 30 procedures a day were done, at the most. Desai was doing 60 procedures in two rooms — a pace that McGregor said compromised patient safety.
The rush of procedures took its toll beyond the forgotten IV needle in Duke Breuer’s arm.
Carrol Lathrop, a 70-year-old from Pahrump, says Desai perforated her bowels during a colonoscopy, and she was forced to wear a colostomy bag for a year before having surgery to fix the problem.
Lathrop’s records from the clinic show Desai performed the procedure on Sept. 6, 2006. The notes are contradictory, observing on the one hand that she was in “discomfort,” “tolerated the procedure poorly” and that the “quality of the prep was inadequate,” while also saying “the colonoscopy was performed without difficulty” and she was discharged in “satisfactory” condition.
The next day, Lathrop was in such agony that she went to Desert View Regional Medical Center in Pahrump where, according to hospital records, she was diagnosed with an “acute perforation” of the sigmoid colon.
McGregor, the California nurse, says she has seen only two cases of perforated bowels in 25 years.
In addition to hurrying procedures, Desai was a miser with supplies, his clinic nurse said. In a finding unrelated to the hepatitis C outbreak, the state Licensure and Certification Bureau found that technicians were not adding the proper amount of detergent to remove the blood, tissue and other body fluids from the endoscopes, nor were they discarding cleaning solution after each use.
In addition, clinic staff was ordered to save money by cutting in half the disposable underpads that protect the beds, she said. The pads cost about 21 cents each.
Desai also saved money — and made money — by using certified nurse anesthetists rather than anesthesiologists, who are medical doctors. Because the certified nurse anesthetists were salaried employees, unlike anesthesiologists, who would have billed insurance companies and Medicare independently, Desai was able to submit his own billings for anesthesiology.
The nurse who worked in the clinic said keeping the anesthesia services in-house offered opportunities to overbill for services. For instance, she said the anesthesia for all procedures was billed at 30 minutes when none ever lasted more than 15.
The Nevada attorney general’s office is investigating whether Desai defrauded insurance companies or Medicaid, the government’s insurance program for the poor.
Using employee-nurses versus outside doctors to administer anesthetics may have contributed to a culture of compliance with Desai’s demands — including the unsanitary injection practices.
Dr. Chris Millson, a Las Vegas-based board member of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, said an independent anesthesiologist would have gone “toe to toe” with Desai and prohibited the dangerous injection practices.
“It’s not that a nurse anesthetist can’t argue with a physician,” Millson said. “But none did in this case.”
On Wednesday, five certified nurse anesthetists voluntarily surrendered their licenses to the Nevada State Board of Nursing pending the outcome of its investigation.
And on Friday Desai voluntarily agreed to cease practicing medicine pending the outcome of an investigation by the Nevada State Board of Medical Examiners.
Discussion: 13 comments so far…
Post a comment
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Editors’ Picks
- Yep, room rates are down
- Trickle-down effect turns upside down
- Sun shines on solar again
- Kill your lawn. Artist gives old adage a water-conscious-in-’08 meaning
- Trop guests relocated after E. coli concerns
- Safe fireworks zones set up outside the Las Vegas Valley
- National Weather Service makes it official, issues heat warning
- Southern Nevada’s college options grow with private start-ups
- Hilton back in boxing biz
- Planetary pillar in the post
Blogs
Cops, Courts and Safety
Las Vegas man killed in two-car collision
Vegas News
Fire danger leads to Red Flag Warning for Las Vegas
Now and Then
Who needs apple pie and Chevrolets when there's baseball and hot dogs at Cashman Field? (1 Comment)
Politics: The Early Line
Heller-Derby congressional race tightens
Culture Blog
Herridge out at Las Vegas Phil
Cops, Courts and Safety
Arizona man dies of heart attack at Lake Mohave
Now and Then
OK, Okahoma City, we're sorry about the rodeo (1 Comment)
Culture Blog
Blues fans alert: Free series moves to Green Valley Ranch as Railhead closes temporarily
Calendar
- Free Swimming and Skating at Clark County Pools (noon to 4 a.m.)
- Summerlin 4th of July Parade (9 a.m. to 11 a.m.)
- Star Spangled Spectacular (7:30 p.m.)
- Rockets Over the River (8:30 p.m.)
-
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
How many people have nightmares of operations going wrong? The wrong limb cut, the muscles and nerves being burned, or not being put under for the entire operation and waking up during surgery? Well, it looks like your dreams can come true if you were a patient at one of these now closed clinics. What I keep thinking is Why? Why did patients not question what was going on and complain about it? A few complaints might have triggered an inspection before now.
Of course I guess that a patient might have been through a few operations and knew when to ask questions about the doctors and procedures. I have had 15 operations on my ankle since 1985. It is now fused with a 16" rod bored into my leg bone so the ankle area could have 10 screws put through the bones into the rod. I learned a lot about hospitals, surgical centers, doctors and nurses. Question everything before you have ANY procedure and most of all before having anesthetics administered to you.
I hope that there are not more infected people and that the ones who are infected receive justice from the courts.
My Aunt DID try to pursue after she was perforated.
NO ONE WOULD LISTEN OR HELP.
Money was talking back then I think...
Sure, like the patient has a voice! I went for the pre-procedure meeting and I got all the bull that they give out in order to make me feel comfortable. Fortunately I had to cancel the appointment and I never rescheduled.
Don't put it off on the patients. The doctors, nurses, administrative staff, etc. should be held accountable. And what about the rest of the medical community? People leave jobs and go to work someplace else and they talk. The medical community had to have known something.
They censored my comment concerning people leaving Nevada, so I guess I am through with the comments in LV Sun!
What concerns me is "one of the states most powerful physicians"
How did he become that? Was it his great medical abilities? Was it his highly ethical business practices? Was it his attention to detail and patient safety?
Or was it his large contributions to politicians and all his money? Maybe when Nevada comes out of the dark ages and gets rid of the good old boys,
power won't be for sale. Our entire government is corrupt. From the politicians to the Judges to the regulators who looked the other way .
And what corrupted them ? MONEY
The voters who followed this doctor and his campaign to limit medical malpractice awards share the blame. Yes money is the reason --the doctor wanted more money. It is a business. When you take away the possibilities of large malpractice awards the risk are worth it. Yes, money is also the answer to the problem. more inspectors and larger awards. We are all humans and if no one is looking corners will be cut; especially if we know there is a limit to the malpratice award.
I am concerned that there were 13 other gastroenterologists working at "Desai's clinics", plus 3 more at the second one closed. Yet it is Dr. Desai alone whose personality and conduct are examined.
Each of the 16 others looked the other way while unsanitary, assembly line practices lined their pockets with dollars.
The press needs to publicly identify each of the other 16 doctors, and subject them to the same spotlight as Dr. Desai. Otherwise, there will be no incentive for other doctors in Las Vegas to forcefully keep their partnerships' rainmakers in line.
After reading this article,,,,all I can say is it makes me even more upset.
My husband awaits his results from having a procedure done at one of these hack and whack places, as others I know await their tests.
My heart goes out to you and so do my prayers.
My husband has not been right since his test that was done in Nov 07 at the burnham clinic. And to think that all of this was going on to so many "victims" and how it is affecting all of us just makes me so angry.
A friend of mine was diagnosed with HEP C and she had always wondered how she got it,,,well now she knows thanks to this person I won't even call a dr,,he is in the same catagory to me as a suicide bomber just that he did not kill himself.
Those that worked for him,,and did not say a word are just as guilty if not MORE SO! How in any moral persons mind in the medical field say this was ok to do,,,they deserve the same if not worse criminal punishment then he does.
I hope they all get what they deserve,,,,because there are so many "victims" that did not get what they asked for which is "injected" with disease due to going for tests to make them better or to find out if there was a problem.
As for it being the patients responsibility yeh right,,,not like over 40,000 people are a bunch of idiots and don't ask questions,,,and take all the precautions they can,,,this is not the "patients" fault whatsoever.
Remember the patient is knocked out and does not know what is going on once the procedure is started,,,
I suggest they take their passports away from him and his family,,as I consider him a flight risk.
Dear Illsaywhatsonmymind: It could have been one of two reasons that noone took your aunt's case. First Medical Malpractice is hard to prove. When this happened, how many nurses would you say would have spoke up about what went on in your aunt's surgery room? They obviously were in more fear of losing their jobs or possibly not being able to get another in the community if Desai was as powerful as they are saying. Second, reason an attorney may not take a Malpractice case anymore is pretty much the same reason as why all this happened. Its not enough money for the trouble for the attorneys. Injury cases are usually 33 1/3 of the sum recovered in settlement and 40% if it goes to trial. When these doctors had a cap placed on the amount a person could sue, I believe the cap is $50,000 against a medical professional (not to sure anymore about facilities). 40% of $50,000 (less costs sometimes) is just not enough for attorneys. That is just one way the cap screwed us all out of decent medical care and justice.
I agree, you are right on Snippy.
If this had happened in his home country (India) he would probably be at the mercy of an unruly mob.
Instead, this 3rd world Scrooge will have all the benefits afforded to him by shyster lawyers and our money-ruled legal system. He'll pay his lawyers with his "blood money", he'll declare bankruptcy, and he'll get off with a slap on the wrist.
In this case, 3rd world mob rule is far too good for him and his "associates". He should be turned over to the families of his victims.
You can take the doctor out of the 3rd world, but you can't take the 3rd world out of the doctor.
<<Each of the 16 others looked the other way while unsanitary, assembly line practices lined their pockets with dollars.>>
Many of the other docs in Desai's group are well-intentioned, good clinicians. But if you're an otherwise good doc and you show up to peform a procedure, you can't help but notice the people around you (staff, nurse-anesthetists) are spending too little preparation time to be adhering to sound hygiene practices. The other docs had a duty to know whether or not patient safety regulations were being followed.
Looks like a clear case of willful criminal negligence. They need to prosecute this doctor, if we can still call him that, to the full extent of the law with max penalty. Also, why didn't anybody blow the whistle? All involved need to be held accountable by the courts.