sun editorial:
No compromising safety
Federal OSHA should rescind decision to relax protections for high-rise workers
Wed, Jun 11, 2008 (2:07 a.m.)
Members and leaders of the ironworkers union chose an opportune day to dress down the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration over a safety issue that emerged after several fatal accidents at Las Vegas Strip construction sites.
They chose Monday to excoriate the federal agency’s relaxation of a rule that for years mandated workers on high-rise projects be protected by safety nets or temporary flooring in case they fell.
The day was chosen because OSHA’s federal director, Ed Foulke, was in town to address the American Society of Safety Engineers and to meet with representatives of companies currently engaged in Strip construction.
“We are outraged by news that Mr. Foulke would come to Las Vegas to pontificate about fatalities and workplace safety matters when he has refused to rescind OSHA compliance directives that have been the center of controversy,” Joe Standley, president of the Western District Council of Ironworkers, told Las Vegas Sun reporter Alexandra Berzon.
Such passion among union officials became more common following the start in March of Berzon’s ongoing series of articles on construction safety. Her opening story reported on the recent deaths of nine workers (two more workers have since been killed) at Strip construction sites, including two who might have been saved had netting or flooring been installed beneath them.
Part of her reporting included the shocking fact that federal OSHA has been undermining safety regulations over the years, including the one requiring protective flooring or nets at all times during high-rise construction. In this revision, it ruled that it would no longer enforce the netting/flooring rule if workers were required to wear safety harnesses.
Many contractors, including those on the Strip sites, then stopped installing them. But harnesses are not always properly secured or even worn, as Berzon has pointed out.
The state agency charged with occupational safety — Nevada OSHA — had followed the new federal standard — until last week. With local contractors agreeing not to protest, and under pressure from the ironworkers, the state agency announced it would once again begin enforcing the original rule, beginning Aug. 1.
We agree with the ironworkers union, whose leaders have told Berzon that they believe OSHA’s relaxation of the rule led to a sharp increase in worker deaths nationwide in recent years.
The federal OSHA should immediately rescind its reinterpretation of the flooring/netting rule. The National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health, a division of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, says “falls from elevations” are one of the leading causes of death among construction workers. It is indeed outrageous that any rule protecting them would be watered down.
Discussion: 1 comment so far…
Post a comment
Email Edition
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Fourth fireworks light up valley sky
- Ensign’s pal lacked usual qualifications for job as senator’s senior aide
- Jay-Z lights up Las Vegas, lives life to the max
- Cousins attracting attention from college football recruiters
- Strip performer is eBay high bidder for Elvis ring
- Las Vegas to sizzle for the Fourth
- Swarm of crickets descends once again on Northern Nevada
- Local conservative radio talk reflects right’s downcast state
- Day 2 of the World Series of Poker main event
- Henderson house fire displaces family of three
Blogs
Elsewhere
Goalie chooses Mudbugs over Wranglers
The Bull's-Eye
Real drama follows Desert Classic victory by 'The Power' (UPDATED)
Elsewhere
Spike TV's 'UFC's Ultimate 100: Greatest Fights' airs tonight
The Kats Report
LV Phil 'Spectacular' at Springs Preserve was great -- for the music
Punchy Points: UFC 100
No. 6: The Ref: Dean relishes role, making right calls (1 Comment)
The Bull's-Eye
Canadian is first in Desert Classic's final four, Barney joins him (UPDATED) (2 Comments)
Sports: Upon Further Review
July 4 at Wimbledon
Calendar
- Blues Monday at the House of Blues (9 p.m. to 11 p.m.)
- Industry Night at XS (10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.)
- The Automatic Tour at The Square Apple (5 p.m. to 9:30 p.m.)
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati
I think that the sun has lost sight of the goal here. The goal here is to prevent falls, period! That is why OSHA allows for the exemption of nets or decking when fall arrest systems are used. Falling into a net or a fully decked level is not going to prevent injury. Falling into decking from a distance of 15 feet or more will be fatal, no doubt in my mind. In 2006, 30% of all fatal falls were from heights less than 10 feet. The only way to truly protect the employees is by eliminating the fall completely. Fall arrest or restraint systems are the most effective way to prevent fall injuries, when used correctly. The greatest issue here is training the employees in proper use and ensuring that it is used every time it is applicable.