Editorial: Right idea, wrong method
Sunday, Feb. 4, 2007 | 7:47 a.m.
A n association of auto body shop operators is pushing for a state law that would assign the Department of Motor Vehicles the responsibility of judging the quality of individual shops.
The Nevada Collision Industry Association wants the Legislature, which starts its 2007 session Monday, to approve the creation of a "Class A" designation for auto body shops. The association also seeks to have the DMV assign and regulate the designation.
Michael Spears, a founding member of the association who owns a Henderson body shop, spoke to Las Vegas Sun reporter Ed Koch. "Wouldn't you as a consumer want to know that the shop that is doing major collision repairs on your car has ongoing training of personnel and certified equipment to make proper repairs?" Spears said.
Most people, including us, would answer yes to that question. But we do not want a state agency, much less the DMV, which can barely keep pace with its current responsibilities, rating the quality of a private business' work.
How is someone from the DMV, or any state agency, supposed to know-whether X brand of equipment is better than Y brand, or whether someone's certificate from a training course equals someone else's 20 years of experience?
Because the Class A designation would give shops that hold it a competitive advantage, the rating system would be vulnerable to corruption. Gifts in exchange for the rating are not hard to imagine.
And if the quality of work by body shops is to be rated by the state, why not have the state rate engine repair shops, tire shops, muffler shops and so on?
The state's Business and Industry Department and its industrial relations division already promote training and safety at job sites, but without offering subjective views on a business' quality of work.
The idea of rating quality is good. But the method should be patterned after the Better Business Bureau model or guides such as those published by Zagat, Fodor, Michelin, AAA and Mobil.
archive
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Vdara hotel marks opening of CityCenter
- Greenspun reorganizes local media operation, cuts staff
- Harry Reid on mortgages: ‘Bank of America must do more’
- A sad day at the Sun, but a day for hope
- UNLV’s poise to be tested in first road game of season
- Employee files lawsuit against Amazon.com, seeks class-action status
- Bail set at $1 million in fatal Thanksgiving Day shooting
- Firefighter jailed for kicking teen boy after basketball game
- Report: Nevada among friendliest states for small businesses
- Tiger Woods allegedly linked to LV nightclub exec
Blogs
The Kats Report
Noteworthy: More from the Trop, Cher changes, Newton on CBS Sunday Morning
TUF Heavyweights
Marathon season finale
Politics: Ralston's Flash
Brian Sandoval is still against taxes, for limiting government and empowering people (6 Comments)
Elsewhere
TCU extends Gary Patterson through 2016
The Kats Report
Dissimilar landmarks -- Binion's and CityCenter -- reflect today's Las Vegas (8 Comments)
High School Sports Scene
Prep Football: State Championship (4 Comments)
Elsewhere
UFC debut in Boston likely July or August (1 Comment)
Calendar »
- 3 Thu
- 4 Fri
- 5 Sat
- 6 Sun
- 7 Mon
-
The Cranberries at The Pearl
The Pearl at the Palms | 8 p.m. to 11 p.m.
-
Grand opening of Crystals at CityCenter
CityCenter-Crystals | 5 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.
-
Sans Age spa night at The Stirling Club featuring Danne' King
Stirling Club | 6 p.m. to 7:30 p.m.
-
Bill Engvall at the Treasure Island Theatre
Treasure Island Theatre
-
Tabor Dame at Stoney’s Rockin’ Country
Stoney's Rockin' Country
-
ILORI sunglass boutique grand opening
Ilori Sunglass Boutique | 5 p.m. to 8 p.m.
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati







