Editorial: Judging a heinous crime
Wednesday, April 4, 2007 | 7:18 a.m.
Carson City District Judge Bill Maddox stunningly declared last week that crimes such as child pornography and having sex with an underage child are not necessarily morally wrong but offenses of "impulse control."
"When I say that, it's my understanding that most men are sexually attracted to young women," Maddox said, according to a transcript of a sentencing hearing posted online by the Nevada Appeal, Carson City's newspaper. "When I say young women, I don't just mean women that ... you should be attracted to. I mean women from the time they're 1 all the way up until they're 100."
That is outrageous and, given the context, particularly frightening. The man he sentenced, 36-year-old Jason Excell, had more than 800 hard-core photos of underage children, some as young as 5.
Maddox brushed off the belief that these crimes are morally wrong, instead defining them by the legal term malum prohibitium, meaning the offense is merely something deemed illegal by society, such as speeding. He said it is illegal to have sexual contact with a child younger than 16, "which flies in the face of our, I guess for lack of a better description, our normal impulses." He based that argument on his finding that "in some societies it's acceptable to be engaging in sexual conduct with women that are 11, 12, 13 years old."
In his statement Maddox blazed a wide, reckless and completely ludicrous path. He defames "most men" by saying they are attracted to young girls, and he minimized sexual crime by saying 11-, 12- and 13-year-old girls are women. Does calling them women make this crime any less morally repugnant?
Victimizing children, whether through the actual act or by promoting their continued violation by buying child pornography, is morally wrong, as are all sexual crimes. Impulse control has nothing to do with it.
Ironically, in giving Excell a sentence of up to 18 years in prison under which he will be eligible for parole in two, Maddox said he wanted to send a message to anyone thinking about buying child pornography. He said there were consequences to pay and "if you get caught possessing them you're going to go to prison in Carson City."
The message that came through, however, was that perpetrators have excuses for such heinous crimes, and that is simply an unacceptable argument from a District Court judge.
archive
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Tiger Woods allegedly linked to LV nightclub exec
- 6 charged in Metro officer’s death appear in NLV court
- Reports: Mayweather Jr. has agreed to fight Pacquiao
- Home prices cut in half in 12 valley ZIP codes over year
- Report: Investors buying up Las Vegas foreclosure homes
- No. 24 UNLV gutsy in 74-72 victory at Arizona
- M Resort notes improved business in recent months
- CityCenter unveils Crystals retail district
- Vdara exec predicts strong sales
- Congress races to restore benefits subsidy for laid-off workers
Blogs
The Kats Report
From Eva Longoria Parker to a cluster of execs, crowd takes a shine to Crystals
Elsewhere
Harry Reid's recipe for getting health-care deal done (3 Comments)
UNLV in at No. 11 in SI's college hoops power rankings (3 Comments)
Top Chef: Las Vegas
Top Chef Episode 13: A few good chefs
Gray Matter
Fight weekend in Las Vegas and Thanksgiving (1 Comment)
Politics: Ralston's Flash
Consultant who knocked off Tom Daschle would love for Lowden to knock off Reid (14 Comments)
Gibbons: Timeline shows lawmakers (especially Marcus Conklin) at fault in unemployment insurance fiasco (1 Comment)
Calendar »
- 4 Fri
- 5 Sat
- 6 Sun
- 7 Mon
- 8 Tue
-
Ray Price at Boulder Station
Boulder Station Hotel and Casino | 8 p.m. to 10 p.m.
-
Clay Walker at The Golden Nugget
Golden Nugget Hotel & Casino
-
Gloriana at LAX
LAX Nightclub | 10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.
-
Brooks & Dunn at the Hilton
Las Vegas Hilton
-
Bill Engvall at the Treasure Island Theatre
Treasure Island Theatre
-
Ron White performs at the Mirage
Terry Fator Theatre
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati










