Editorial: Reprieve for assisted suicide
Thursday, Jan. 19, 2006 | 7:30 a.m.
In the 1994 general election, Oregon voters approved the Death With Dignity Act and it was passed into law by that state's Legislature.
It permits doctors to prescribe lethal drugs to terminally ill patients who are mentally competent and who have been medically determined to have less than six months to live. Two doctors must verify these conditions before the drugs can be prescribed. After surviving federal court challenges, resistance from some state lawmakers and a ballot initiative against it, the law finally became effective in 1997.
Then-Sen. John Ashcroft, R-Mo., tried in vain to block the law with appeals to then-Attorney General Janet Reno, federal court challenges and a bill he co-sponsored. After becoming attorney general, one of his first acts was to declare the law in violation of a federal regulation under the Controlled Substances Act, which states that all prescriptions must be issued for a "legitimate medical purpose." Ashcroft reasoned that assisted suicide is not a legitimate medical purpose.
On Tuesday the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that it was Ashcroft's reasoning that was not legitimate. Voting 6-3, the court ruled that Ashcroft took the regulation out of context and imposed federal power over a state without authorization from Congress. The court further said the Controlled Substances Act was written to control the flow of illicit drugs, not those legally prescribed by a doctor.
Dissenting were Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas. Scalia, who wrote the dissent, argued that Ascroft's interpretation of "legitimate medical purpose" was "clearly valid." He wrote that the word legitimate "connotes an objective standard of medicine," which, from the days of Hippocrates, has always meant "prevention, cure or alleviation of disease." Assisted suicide, he wrote, does not meet any of those definitions.
The majority opinion, however, did not dwell on semantics or the morality of Oregon's law. It confined itself to the question of whether Congress had ever given Ashcroft the authority to override Oregon's law. It hadn't.
And as far as this issue is concerned, we hope Congress continues to let states decide for themselves. Of course, states should include safeguards similar to Oregon's law, and allow lengthy debate before putting a proposed physician-assisted suicide law before voters or the Legislature.
archive
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Trial delayed for man accused of shooting 3 officers
- Kruger hoping his team will play with grit
- Ten minutes with Chelsea Handler is better than no minutes with Chelsea Handler
- Pricing out wagers on the Pacquiao-Cotto fight
- RTC bus driver fired, arrested after allegedly attacking woman
- Two second-graders involved in shooting at bus stop
- CityCenter Realtors hit with cut in commissions
- Privé owner files for bankruptcy protection in Florida
- Shanghai’s maglev: Flying with both feet on the ground
- Trainers scuffle at Manny Pacquiao, Miguel Cotto weigh-in
Blogs
The Greene Room
Predicting this weekend's Mountain West football slate
Top Chef: Las Vegas
Top Chef Episode 11: Child's play
Miech Again
UNLV prez Smatresk is ready for some basketball (5 Comments)
Politics: The Early Line
Harry Reid's fourth TV ad begins running today
The Greene Room
Chad Ochocinco vs. Anderson Silva? That would be a sight ... (4 Comments)
Top Chef: Las Vegas
The Jet Stream: The three stages of chefdom
Miech Again
Rebels rookie Lopez says redshirting is his best move (12 Comments)
Calendar »
- 14 Sat
- 15 Sun
- 16 Mon
- 17 Tue
- 18 Wed
-
Pacquiao vs. Cotto at the MGM Grand Garden Arena
MGM Grand Garden Arena | 6 p.m. to 11 p.m.
-
Friends of India Diwali Celebration at Cashman Field with Dan Nainan
Cashman Field | 7:30 p.m. to 10 p.m.
-
Norm MacDonald at the House of Blues
House of Blues
-
Boulder City Art Guild Winter Fest Fine Art Show
Boulder City Parks & Recreation
-
John Fogerty at the Star of the Desert Arena
Star of the Desert Arena | 8 p.m. to 11 p.m.
-
Emeril Lagasse Foundation’s 5th annual Carnivale du Vin
The Venetian Resort Hotel Casino | 6 p.m. to 10 p.m.
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati








