Editorial: Rules are set in stone
Tuesday, Aug. 24, 2004 | 9:23 a.m.
All is fair in love and war, but not in sports, where wronged participants, in the end, must ask: What is the game we play and what are the rules?
South Korean gymnast Yang Tae-young was decidedly wronged Wednesday in Athens. Judges erred in deducting 0.1 point from the start value (the number of points a gymnast would earn if he performed perfectly) of his parallel bars routine in the competition for best all-around gymnast. Tae-young's start value should have been 10.0 but the judges placed it at 9.90. After his performance, judges awarded him 9.712, which theoretically would have been 9.812 without the error in start value.
At the end of the all-around competition, American Paul Hamm won the gold and Tae-young won the bronze. Just 0.049 points separated the two. Mathematically, had it not been for the judges' error, the gold would have gone to Tae-young.
Of course, there are intangibles. E.M. Swift of Sports Illustrated writes, "Yang might have relaxed with the bigger lead; he might have become uptight and choked; ... Judges, too, might have scored his high-bar routine differently had he been further ahead than he was at the time."
Paul Hamm should keep his gold medal and wear it proudly. Excepting a slip in the vault competition, he performed brilliantly and no error by any judge can take that away. And Tae-young should keep his bronze medal, and also wear it with pride. He, too, competed brilliantly but must accept that he missed the gold, however unfairly, by the rules governing his sport. The rules say protests against judgments must be made immediately, during the meet. The South Koreans never protested until after the medals had been given out.
Strict abidance by the rules during events may at times be unfair to an individual athlete, but the competition itself is protected. If they were allowed, after-the-fact protests would dominate the Olympics, and that would be unfair to everybody.
archive
Spotlight
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Firefighters union takes action to silence critic Sisolak
- Dina Titus to vote ‘yes’ on health care reform
- Woman, shot in face and left for dead, survives to testify
- 150 birds, dog die in fire at Las Vegas sanctuary
- The Vegas Channel scam netted woman $200,000, officials say
- Report: Men shot by homeowner were looking for items to steal
- One and done: Late trey helps Northern Iowa bury UNLV
- Ensign’s refusal to resign harms many in his circle
- Technology is king at the M Resort sports book
- Pass health care reform
Blogs
The Kats Report
From Sammy Davis Jr. to Fred Astaire, Rick Faugno has it coverered
Bloggity, Bloggity, Bloggity
NASCAR drivers have memories like elephants
The Greene Room
Well what do you know ... Northern Iowa's done this before (2 Comments)
Rebel on the Road
Tough loss felt by this loyal fan (5 Comments)
Politics: Ralston's Flash
Gibbons, lawmakers go to Supreme Court to try to compel water folks to transfer $62 million to state (4 Comments)
Rebel on the Road
Ready for the experience of a lifetime with UNLV basketball (2 Comments)
Elsewhere
Grand jury subpoenas Ensign-tied companies (12 Comments)
Calendar »
- 20 Sat
- 21 Sun
- 22 Mon
- 23 Tue
- 24 Wed
-
Jeff Dunham at The Colosseum
The Colosseum
-
Las Vegas Wranglers vs. Alaska Aces
The Orleans Arena
-
Bill Bellamy at South Point
South Point Showroom
-
Jo Koy at the Mirage
Terry Fator Theatre | 10 p.m. to 11:30 p.m.
-
March Birthday Party at McFadden's
McFadden's Restaurant and Saloon | 10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.
-
Paul Oakenfold and Eddie Halliwell at Perfecto
Rain Nightclub | 10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.
-
Tyson Ritter of All-American Rejects at Haze
Haze Nightclub | 10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati



















