High court allows insanity defense
Wednesday, July 25, 2001 | 10:17 a.m.
CARSON CITY -- The Nevada Supreme Court in a split decision has ruled that a criminal defendant must be allowed to raise the defense of insanity to avoid conviction.
The court said the 1995 Legislature was wrong to abolish the right of a defendant to enter a plea of "not guilty by reason of insanity."
"The Legislature cannot abolish the concept of legal insanity," Justice Nancy Becker wrote in the majority opinion.
The decision, issued Tuesday, allowed Frederick Finger to withdraw his plea of guilty but mentally ill to second-degree murder in the fatal stabbing of his mother, Franziska Brassaw, in Las Vegas in April 1996. She was stabbed once in the head with a kitchen knife at their home.
Finger, who was sentenced to life in prison, sought to enter a plea of "not guilty by reason of insanity." The District Court judge, however, told him that plea had been repealed by the Legislature. He entered the guilty plea but claimed he was mentally ill.
Becker said Finger had the right to argue he lacked the required intent to commit the crime because he was mentally ill.
"The attempt by the Legislature to wipe away more than a century of criminal jurisprudence tramples on the due process rights of mentally unsound defendants and is unconstitutional," Justice Myron Leavitt, in a concurring opinion, said.
However, wrote Justice Miriam Shearing in the dissent, the present law does not violate either the U.S. or Nevada Constitution. She said under the Nevada law, Finger was not required to plead guilty.
"Every person accused of a crime has a right to a trial," she said. Finger, she said, could have refused to enter a plea and the District Court would have been required to enter a plea of not guilty. Then a trial could be held at which evidence of the mental state of Finger could have been presented by the defense.
Dissenting were Justice Miriam Shearing, Chief Justice Bill Maupin and Justice Bob Rose.
Joining Becker and Leavitt in the majority decision were Justices Cliff Young and Deborah Agosti. They said Finger has the right to argue he lacked the required intent to commit murder and is legally insane.
archive
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Trial delayed for man accused of shooting 3 officers
- Kruger hoping his team will play with grit
- Ten minutes with Chelsea Handler is better than no minutes with Chelsea Handler
- Pricing out wagers on the Pacquiao-Cotto fight
- RTC bus driver fired, arrested after allegedly attacking woman
- Two second-graders involved in shooting at bus stop
- CityCenter Realtors hit with cut in commissions
- Privé owner files for bankruptcy protection in Florida
- Shanghai’s maglev: Flying with both feet on the ground
- Trainers scuffle at Manny Pacquiao, Miguel Cotto weigh-in
Blogs
The Greene Room
Predicting this weekend's Mountain West football slate
Top Chef: Las Vegas
Top Chef Episode 11: Child's play
Miech Again
UNLV prez Smatresk is ready for some basketball (5 Comments)
Politics: The Early Line
Harry Reid's fourth TV ad begins running today
The Greene Room
Chad Ochocinco vs. Anderson Silva? That would be a sight ... (4 Comments)
Top Chef: Las Vegas
The Jet Stream: The three stages of chefdom
Miech Again
Rebels rookie Lopez says redshirting is his best move (12 Comments)
Calendar »
- 14 Sat
- 15 Sun
- 16 Mon
- 17 Tue
- 18 Wed
-
Pacquiao vs. Cotto at the MGM Grand Garden Arena
MGM Grand Garden Arena | 6 p.m. to 11 p.m.
-
Friends of India Diwali Celebration at Cashman Field with Dan Nainan
Cashman Field | 7:30 p.m. to 10 p.m.
-
Norm MacDonald at the House of Blues
House of Blues
-
Boulder City Art Guild Winter Fest Fine Art Show
Boulder City Parks & Recreation
-
John Fogerty at the Star of the Desert Arena
Star of the Desert Arena | 8 p.m. to 11 p.m.
-
Emeril Lagasse Foundation’s 5th annual Carnivale du Vin
The Venetian Resort Hotel Casino | 6 p.m. to 10 p.m.
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati








