State eyeing appeal in battle over Yucca water
Thursday, Dec. 27, 2001 | 9:37 a.m.
CARSON CITY -- The state may appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court in its fight to stop the Energy Department from getting water rights to operate the proposed nuclear dump at Yucca Mountain.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals this week rejected the state's petition to reconsider its earlier decision that handed the Energy Department a procedural victory in its effort to gain permanent water rights at Yucca.
Nevada Deputy Attorney General Paul Taggart said today there's been confusion over the case and "it merits going to the U.S. Supreme Court." He said, however, that he would have to confer with the state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources.
Mike Turnipseed, while he was state engineer, denied the application of the federal agency, noting Nevada law prohibits a nuclear dump. Turnipseed now heads the conservation department.
The Energy Department then filed suit, contesting the Turnipseed ruling, claiming federal law pre-empts state law.
U.S. District Judge Roger Hunt in Las Vegas ruled in favor of the state. But the Circuit Court, in its 2-1 ruling, sent the case back to Hunt to decide whether the federal Nuclear Waste Policy Act supersedes the Nevada law that bars a nuclear dump in Nevada.
The state asked the Circuit Court to reconsider its split decision. But it refused. Taggart said the court never gave a reason for its denial. "There was no discussion of the merits," he said.
Taggart said there has been a "fundamental misunderstanding" by the Circuit Court that the issue was the water that is now being used by the Energy Department in studying the site. The federal agency, Taggart said, has the rights for this temporary use.
This legal fight is over the permanent water rights. The state maintains the suit by the energy department is premature because President Bush and Congress have yet to designate Yucca as the permanent burial grounds for nuclear waste.
There is also a suit pending in the District Court in Tonopah over the water rights. And the state says the issue should be decided there before the federal court steps in.
The Circuit Court, in its original ruling, said, "Although the location of a nuclear waste repository is plainly a sensitive social issue, it is not the issue in this case."
The court said, "The issue in this case is whether the Nuclear Waste Policy Act preempts Nevada Revised Statute," which says the construction of a dump would be detrimental to the state's public interest.
It said that if the federal act is interpreted to mean that only the federal government is entitled to determine whether Yucca Mountain is suitable, then the Energy Department wins.
But Nevada will triumph if the federal nuclear law is interpreted to permit Nevada to take part in the decision making, above and beyond just filing a "notice of disapproval" of the site, as allowed in the federal law.
archive
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Man, 18, arrested for DUI in crash that kills woman, 24
- Man fatally shot during robbery attempt of woman
- Binion’s to close all 365 rooms, lay off 100 workers
- Ex-NBA star to pay $12,835 monthly in gambling debt case
- Slot makers team up at behest of CityCenter
- “Last Call!”: Two words you wouldn’t expect to hear on The Strip
- Now, Rebels must build on big Louisville win
- Report: 70 percent of homeowners underwater
- Nevada leads nation in rate of bankruptcy filings
- What reactions to Palin, Stewart say about society
Blogs
The Kats Report
Planet Hollywood's Thomas McCartney headed for Tropicana (4 Comments)
Elsewhere
LV woman robs Kentucky strip club, police say (2 Comments)
Las Vegas Sands' Hong Kong IPO flops
The Kats Report
Monday List: Top 13 Moments and Observations From Thanksgiving Weekend (2 Comments)
Politics: Ralston's Flash
Tarkanian: Reid is liberal, out of touch, rude, poisonously partisan and a know-it-all (5 Comments)
The Kats Report
Barry Manilow off to Paris: Two-year deal starts March 5 at Le Theatre des Arts (10 Comments)
Politics: Ralston's Flash
Ensign survives radio interview with no follow-ups; partial transcript below (4 Comments)
Calendar »
- 1 Tue
- 2 Wed
- 3 Thu
- 4 Fri
- 5 Sat
-
Grand opening of Vdara
Vdara | 10 a.m. to 11:59 p.m.
-
Dik Richie at Moon
Moon Nightclub | 10:30 p.m. to 11:59 p.m.
-
A Night to Honor Israel at the Cashman Theatre
Cashman Convention Center | 7 p.m. to 10 p.m.
-
Ladies night at Feelgoods
Feelgoods
-
Sin City Sinners at VooDoo Lounge
VooDoo Steak & Lounge
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati






