Judge upholds recount

Ann Gearan

Monday, Nov. 13, 2000 | 11:23 a.m.

MIAMI -- A federal judge today allowed hand recounts to proceed in Florida's closely contested presidential election, handing a legal victory to Al Gore and a setback to George W. Bush. Republicans said a decision would be made swiftly about an appeal.

"A federal court has a very limited role and should not intervene," U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks ruled in Miami after hearing arguments on a GOP lawsuit calling for a halt to the Democratic-requested recounts under way or planned in scattered counties.

"While I share a desire for finality, I do not believe it is served" by issuing the order sought by Bush's lawyers, he added.

The ruling, which Middlebrooks himself said was likely to be appealed by the Republicans, marked the latest turn in a presidential election now nearly one week past the balloting with no end in sight.

The winner of Florida's 25 electoral votes stands to gain an Electoral College majority and become the nation's 43rd president. Bush has a 388-vote lead in an unofficial tally by the Associated Press, but Middlebrooks' ruling clears the way, temporarily at least, for either side to seek additional hand recounts that could affect the count.

The ruling came a short while after Florida's top election official pledged to wrap up the vote recount by Tuesday afternoon. Democrats suggested the secretary of state was motivated by her Republican affiliation, and her effort to meet the deadline was thrown into doubt by the legal maneuvering in at least two courtrooms around the state.

Middlebrooks said the procedures for manual recounts appear to be politically neutral. Republicans had argued that a manual recount in just a handful of counties selected by the Democrats -- rather than all 67 -- would dilute the vote of people elsewhere in the state.

He said he considered that a serious argument but insufficient to warrant intervention.

Earlier, Middlebrooks, an appointee of President Clinton, had signaled clearly he understood the gravity of the case before him and the likelihood his decision would be appealed.

"I am not under an illusion I am the last word on this, and I am rather grateful for that," he said.

A separate hearing was set in Volusia County in state court. The Democratic-controlled canvassing board there filed suit seeking permission to work beyond Secretary of State Katherine Harris' deadline, if necessary.

She said the recount should be finished by 5 p.m. Tuesday with a winner certified by Saturday, after an unknown number of overseas absentee ballots are rolled into the totals.

"The law unambiguously states when the process of counting and recounting the votes cast on Election Day must end," Harris said in a written statement distributed in Tallahassee.

"For this election, that time is 5 p.m. Nov. 14, which is tomorrow."

In another closely contested state, New Mexico, Republican Party attorneys are requesting that state police impound early voting and absentee ballots from Tuesday's election in case of a challenge or recount. Bush holds a 17-vote margin.

Police seized ballots in seven counties during the weekend under orders from two state District Court judges. The counties comprise two judicial districts. GOP officials say impoundment petitions will be filed in all 13 New Mexico judicial districts.

Both sides seemed to be guessing that the Texas governor's margin would grow when the overseas votes were tallied.

That made the hand recounts, and the court arguments, critical. Already, officials in Volusia and Palm Beach counties were deep into hand recounts. Officials arranged to begin sorting through thousands of ballots in Broward County today, and in Miami-Dade, the canvassing board set a meeting for Tuesday to decide how to proceed.

The attorneys couched their arguments to Middlebrooks in much the same terms the two sides have used in public statements since the Florida dispute flared in the hours after the polls closed last week.

"The process, to sum it up, is selective, standardless, subjective, unreliable and inherently biased," said GOP lawyer Theodore Olson.

Olson said the hand count introduced elements of chance and partisan bias to what ought to be a simple and uniform process of checking Florida's extraordinarily close election result.