High Court limits liability of governments
Tuesday, July 28, 1998 | 10:55 a.m.
CARSON CITY -- The Nevada Supreme Court, in a 3-2 decision, ruled Monday that people who are wronged by the actions of governments cannot collect a money judgment from more than one government.
The court said that to permit suits filed against a number of governments arising from a single incident "may have a massive and deleterious effect upon state and local treasuries."
The decision overturns a pretrial ruling by Clark County District Judge Donald Mosley, who held that a suit by a Las Vegas couple could be pursued against University Medical Center even though they had received $150,000 from the state.
Martha Upchurch gave birth in July 1990 to a baby who suffered from cerebral palsy. The parents blamed the hospital and physicians Donald Roberts and Edward Spoon, who were obstetric-gynecology residents employed by the state and the University of Nevada Medical School.
The state agreed to settle, paying the maximum $50,000 each to the father, mother and child. The parents also sued University Medical Center, which said they were not entitled to collect from a second judgment.
The hospital argued that the Legislature intended for a limit to apply to a law covering suits against governments that allows payment based on the number of claimants and the number of wrongs committed. It said the parents could not collect from the hospital after getting paid by the state.
District Judge Richard Wagner of Lovelock, who wrote the majority decision, said there was no direct evidence that the Legislature ever considered this issue. Wagner, who sat in for Justice William Maupin, said that in the absence of clear "legislative guidance," the court would practice "judicial restraint" in ruling that only one government can be made to pay.
Chief Justice Charles Springer dissented, saying both the state and the hospital should be held liable.
The law, Springer said, permits an action against any political subdivision. "This means to me that one can sue and recover judgment against the state, a county government and a city government, if each has been proven to be independently liable for tortious conduct.
"Judgment, in such a case, could be awarded against each, and each would have to pay up to the $50,000 statutory limit," Springer said. Justice Bob Rose joined in the Springer dissent.
archive
- Most Read
- Discussed
- Most E-mailed
- Live Blog: Pacquiao wins by TKO in round twelve
- Police seek man who stole $2,000 worth of clothing
- Clubs want to be ‘good citizen,’ so stripper-mobile ends its run
- Nuclear plant in Ely could complicate radioactive waste, water issues
- Floyd Mayweather Jr. and Manny Pacquiao: The only fight fans want to see
- Now we can all see Islamic extremism for what it truly is
- Manny Pacquiao says he feels stronger than ever
- Ensign Federal Credit Union fails
- Small city struggles with shocking allegations
- Bruised and battered, Cotto says he will fight again
Blogs
Elsewhere
Dana White continues to push for event in Abu Dhabi
Politics: Ralston's Flash
Harry Reid is powerful for Northern Nevada, too!
The Kats Report
New face of Monte Carlo includes all the faces of Caliendo
The Greene Room
Predicting this weekend's Mountain West football slate (2 Comments)
Top Chef: Las Vegas
Top Chef Episode 11: Child's play
Miech Again
UNLV prez Smatresk is ready for some basketball (11 Comments)
Politics: The Early Line
Harry Reid's fourth TV ad begins running today
Calendar »
- 15 Sun
- 16 Mon
- 17 Tue
- 18 Wed
- 19 Thu
-
Actor's Expo at Rave Motion Pictures
Rave Motion Pictures Town Square 18 | 3 p.m. to 5 p.m.
-
Lily Tomlin at the Hollywood Theatre
Hollywood Theatre at MGM Grand
-
Neil Sedaka at the Orleans
Orleans Hotel-Casino
-
Supernatural Santana – A Trip Through the Hits at The Joint
The Joint
The Sun
Locally owned and independent for more than 50 years.
Technorati





